Wählen Sie aus verschiedenen Englisch Lehrkräften für ...
China flagAndrea
A grammar question in AP News "And it's a rare sight during a Chicago winter. But this hummingbird which showed up just before Thanksgiving is attracting a bit of a following. The birds stayed for 7 weeks before apparently heading south for the winter. " In the last sentence, why is it "the birds stayed for 7 weeks before"? Not "the birds stayed since 7 weeks before" or "the birds has stayed 7 weeks before"? Because I thought that I shouldn't put "for" behind a past simple tense. So is there any grammar knowledge here? And here's another question: does the last sentence mean the birds have stayed for 7 weeks and it shows the winter is coming? You can watch the video here : http://bit.ly/zD8TGx . Thanks!Sorry, I should ask: Why is it "the birds stayed for 7 weeks before"? Not "the birds stayed since 7 weeks ago" or "the birds has stayed 7 weeks"? OK.. REALLY sorry for my mistakes... I should ask: Why is it "the birds stayed for 7 weeks before"? Not "the birds stayed 7 weeks ago" or "the birds has stayed since the last 7 weeks"?

Antworten · 3

0
This is how you divide up the sentence: "The birds stayed / for 7 weeks / before apparently heading south / for the winter." Pretty clear! :)
0
Here's a very easy rule that will make this clear: when you have a COUNTING number, use "for." So in your example, "7 weeks" has a counting number of "7"--if you said, "since December" or "since last week" or "since 1972," you would not have a counting number, so you use "since" (1972 is a number, but it's a date, not a counting number).
0
我想是需要一个介词来引导时间,比如7点去学校,go to school at 7 a.m. 而for是一个表示时间持续的介词。 光有一个时间不能在句子中间发生关系吧。 第一个意思应该是‘鸟之前在这里停留了7个礼拜’,而后一句是,鸟在7个礼拜之前停在这里。 注意,这两句表达的意思不同哦。 第三句应该也要加for。来配合stay表达时间。为什么用for,因为你用别的单词不对嘛,比如说at,in,after,再说和句子表达的意思不一样。for是最好的

Haben Sie noch keine Antworten gefunden?

Geben Sie Ihre Fragen ein und lassen Sie sich von Muttersprachlern helfen!

Verpassen Sie nicht die Gelegenheit, bequem von zu Hause aus eine Sprache zu lernen. Stöbern Sie in unserer Auswahl an erfahrenen Sprachlehrern und melden Sie sich jetzt zu Ihrer ersten Unterrichtsstunde an!

Heute mit dem Lernen beginnen