Dominic
estar & ser example mon abuelo es muerto OR ésta?
3. Jan. 2017 14:10
Antworten · 9
"mi abuelo esta muerto" my grandpa is dead. En español uno esta muerto, no es muerto, unlike english.
3. Januar 2017
Hi Dominic! Please check the Webseite sometimes grammatical rules are not pure mathematics: http://spanish.about.com/od/usingparticularverbs/a/muerto.htm They also ask themselves the same question why not: "Mi padre es muerto" Best!
4. Januar 2017
It is "estar muerto". Many Spanish teachers will state that "estar" is used to describe temporary conditions whereas "ser" is used to discuss permanence. However, this is not entirely accurate as illustrated in this example. In the case of "estar muerto", we are contrasting two states of being. In this case you are either "muerto" or "vivo". This is why we use "estar" here.
27. April 2021
Mi abuelo es un hombre muy sabio (what kind of man he is) very clever or wise Mi abuelo era un hombre muy sabio ( what kind of man he was) Mi abuelo está vivo/ muerto ( his state/condition) he is alive/dead
4. Januar 2017
Hi, Dominic! The correct form to say that is "Mi abuelo está muerto". Espero haberte ayudado. If you have anyother question, dont hesitate to contact me. ¡Saludos!
4. Januar 2017
Mehr anzeigen
Haben Sie noch keine Antworten gefunden?
Geben Sie Ihre Fragen ein und lassen Sie sich von Muttersprachlern helfen!