Are these four sentences correct expression?
My student said "The black car was full of people, which was very crowded."
Is this expression right in grammar?
I want to give her another example as follows. Is this sentence correct?
The basket is full of stinky socks, which is very smelly.
The other student wrote:
He looked at the food next to him, could not help but eat a few mouthfuls.
I want to give her a feedback as follows.
He looked at the food next to him, and could not help but eat a few bites of it.
Wählen Sie aus verschiedenen Englisch Lehrkräften für ...
Antworten · 6
2
Hi Daisy,
My student said "The black car was full of people, which was very crowded."
Is this expression right in grammar?
As an example: The zoo which is five miles away is closed permanently.
The word "which" connects "zoo" to additional information "five miles away".
We use the pronoun "which" to provide more information on "people". Your student's sentence sounds odd as it might be mistaken as the "people" were "very crowded".
The student should simply write: "The black car was full of people."
I want to give her another example as follows. Is this sentence correct?
The basket is full of stinky socks, which is very smelly.
This sentence is fine, except for "is". There are many pairs of socks. This requires the word "are". The sentence does not require a comma, as the pronoun "which" links two parts of the sentence together.
Having said that, "stinky" already has the meaning of "smelly". So the meaning is repeated in the sentence. Perhaps you may want to write: "The basket is full of stinky socks which is a concern for me.
The other student wrote:
He looked at the food next to him, could not help but eat a few mouthfuls.
Yes, there are two separate pieces of information. 1) looked at the food next to him. 2) very tempted and took a few mouthfuls of food. You can use the conjunction "and".
I want to give her a feedback as follows.
He looked at the food next to him, and could not help but (took) a few (mouthfuls).
Hope this helps.
Cheers,
Lance
1
Hmm I don't think you would use the word 'crowded' as a crowd would imply more people than would fit into a car. You might say 'the black car was full of people, nobody had any room to move' or 'the black car was full of people, they were all packed in'. In your example I might say 'are' very smelly since it is the socks (plural) that smell, not the basket. I think the food sentence is good but I would either put 'and' or 'but' as a connective in the middle. Hope that helps!
1
你好,Daisy!
前面两个句子的语法都对的,但是逗号后面的话很冗余,所以实际上不需要:
"The black car was full of people." 这句话里面有 "full of people",所以已经够了,不需要再说 "which was very crowded"。
"The basket is full of of stinky socks." 跟第一个句子一样的,"stinky socks" 已经表示味道难闻了,所以不用加 "which is very smelly"。
后面修改的是对的,只要把逗号去掉就可以了。
希望我回答了你的问题。如果没有请跟我说。
Haben Sie noch keine Antworten gefunden?
Geben Sie Ihre Fragen ein und lassen Sie sich von Muttersprachlern helfen!
Verpassen Sie nicht die Gelegenheit, bequem von zu Hause aus eine Sprache zu lernen. Stöbern Sie in unserer Auswahl an erfahrenen Sprachlehrern und melden Sie sich jetzt zu Ihrer ersten Unterrichtsstunde an!
Heute mit dem Lernen beginnen
