I like your thinking/the way you think/your way of thinking
【Teacher: "Listen carefully: Four crows are on the fence. The farmer shoots one. How many are left?"
Little Johnny: "None."
Teacher: "Can you explain that answer?"
Little Johnny: "One is shot, the others fly away. There are none left."
Teacher: "Well, that isn't the correct answer, but I like the way you think."】

My question is if we can use"I like your thinking","I like your way of thinking" or "I like your thought" instead in this situation? I can't tell the subtle difference between these four.

Question

I like your thinking/the way you think/your way of thinking
【Teacher: "Listen carefully: Four crows are on the fence. The farmer shoots one. How many are left?"
    Little Johnny: "None."
    Teacher: "Can you explain that answer?"
    Little Johnny: "One is shot, the others fly away. There are none left."
    Teacher: "Well, that isn't the correct answer, but I like the way you think."】

My question is if we can use"I like your thinking","I like your way of thinking" or "I like your thought" instead in this situation? I can't tell the subtle difference between these four.

Answer

Yes, "I like your thought' would not work here.  Also, there is a subtle difference.  With the '-ing' verb (I like your thinking, I like your way of thinking) gives the idea/notion that the thinking that is happening is somewhat continuous e.g., there is no specific end) whereas 'I like the way you think' is a statement that is clear and definite.  There is no need to add the '-ing'.

Answer

Thank you, German vogel. Yeah, I agree with you. I should have left out "I like your thought".

Answer

I think all are interchangeable, except for "I like your thought" which doesn't sound natural and is also different in meaning (the others refer to the way of thinking, not to a particular thought).

Verpassen Sie nicht die Gelegenheit, bequem von zu Hause aus eine Sprache zu lernen. Stöbern Sie in unserer Auswahl an erfahrenen Sprachlehrern und melden Sie sich jetzt zu Ihrer ersten Unterrichtsstunde an!