Mai
行くバスvs. 行ったバス あれは 病院 へ。。。バスです。 1。行く 2。行きます 3。行って 4。行った 正しい答えは4です。 Please help explain why 行く is incorrect in this case. Many thanks!
7. Dez. 2017 11:05
Antworten · 4
行く→The bas don't go to the hospital yet 行った→The bas already went to the hospital
10. Dezember 2017
First, based on the sentence structure, options 2) and 3) are not possible, since it requires a noun-modifier for "bus (バス)", and thus either the plain-form (dictionary form) or "-ta (-た)" form (past tense of the dictionary form) can be used. In my personal point of view, If one is on the street, and there is a bus which goes to the hospital, then it should be "あれは 病院 へ行くバスです", i.e., option 1. If one is given a photo (or a video clip), and there shows a bus which goes to the hospital, then it would probably be "あれは 病院 へ行ったバスです", i.e., option 4. === 良い一日をお過ごしください。/I wish you a good day.
7. Dezember 2017
i would say あのバスは病院行きです
7. Dezember 2017
The sentence「あれは病院へ行ったバスです。」sounds strange to me...I think the correct answer is 「あれは病院へ行くバスです」. Sorry for lacking of explanation in detail, but using 行った in this case is unusual.
7. Dezember 2017
Haben Sie noch keine Antworten gefunden?
Geben Sie Ihre Fragen ein und lassen Sie sich von Muttersprachlern helfen!