Wählen Sie aus verschiedenen Englisch Lehrkräften für ...
Michelle Su
Does the usage of There is/are have exceptions? There is a book on the table.

There are flowers in the park.

We don't say, the table has a book or the park has flowers, correct?

Only when the subjects are living creatures can use has or have, right?

Such as I have a book.

But I was wondering if there are any exceptions? Cauz I feel like I've heard of it somewhere. Like can I say "Books that have no pictures are boring."?

Thank you : )

Antworten · 4

2
It is perfectly possible to use a possessive has/have for non-living objects, there is no such rule. The park has flowers is perfectly acceptable.
2
You can use it this way to show location. The book (subject) is on the table (because you needed to know the location of the subject) You can use it this way to give extra information Please come with me to look at this new dress I want to buy. The dress (subject) has pockets. (in this case, I'm giving you additional information) However, it depends on the information you are trying to give. You can combine them. Please bring me my keys. They (the keys) are on the table (location) that has the flowers on it (additional information) (in this case, you would understand that there is more than one table and only one table has flowers on it).
1
It’s true that The subject of a sentence tends to be a person, but if an inanimate object is capable of performing the action or experiencing the state, that inanimate object can function as the subject of the sentence. In English, we usually try to make the *topic* (i.e., the person or thing we want to talk about) the grammatical subject. That is one reason English makes such frequent use of the passive voice. In a way, you could think of “there is / are” as a sort of passive form of “has / have.” Your sentence is correct English: "Books that have no pictures are boring." Note that it’s also possible to reduce the relative clause by replacing “that have” with “with” and “that don’t have” or “that have no” with “without:” “Books without pictures are boring. We use “books” as the subject of the sentence because it is the topic that we want to talk about. If we wanted to talk about the pictures, then we might use “there is / are.” For example: “There are pictures (that were) drawn by a famous artist in the book.” Or “there are pictures in the book that were drawn by a famous artist.” We could also use “to be” without “there:” The pictures (that are) in the book were drawn by a famous artist. If we wanted to talk about the artist, we could say “A famous artist drew some of the pictures (that are) in the book.” Another (simpler) example: The town has three good restaurants. (The town is the topic, so we make it the subject.) There are three good restaurants in the town. (The restaurants are the topic, so we make them the subject.)

Haben Sie noch keine Antworten gefunden?

Geben Sie Ihre Fragen ein und lassen Sie sich von Muttersprachlern helfen!

Verpassen Sie nicht die Gelegenheit, bequem von zu Hause aus eine Sprache zu lernen. Stöbern Sie in unserer Auswahl an erfahrenen Sprachlehrern und melden Sie sich jetzt zu Ihrer ersten Unterrichtsstunde an!

Heute mit dem Lernen beginnen