Difference between the articles. How to explain?
Hello! I have a text of a person describing a photo of a man: "He is dressed in THE black hat, THE white suit, THE brown shoes. "
Could you give me a hand in how to explain that she should use an indefinite article?
The usual explanation "we are not talking about any special hat, suit, shoes" is confusing for a student, because from her opinion she IS talking about a SPECIFIC hat, etc - those that are in the picture.
Thank you!
Wählen Sie aus verschiedenen Englisch Lehrkräften für ...
Antworten · 5
1
In your example A would be used because it is the first time the items of clothing have been mentioned. It is not because of specificity.
Ex.: Look! There's A spider(1st time use indefinite) in my bed. THE spider (2nd time so use definite) is huge!
I'd say something like this for your picture:
There's A man. (Indefinite article used because it's the1st time man was mentioned)
THE man (2nd time so it's now specific/definite) is wearing A black hat (1st time mentioned so indefinite).
1
Hmmm... as someone who's a native speaker but not a teacher, that's a tough one to explain. I'd say that if she were to point to a picture and say "he's wearing the black hat," in order for it to make sense the learner would have to have previously known which hat she was talking about. If there was no previously known context or reference to the hat in the conversation, it's still just a nonspecific black hat. Hope that makes sense.
0
I am miss Rainna i like to have communication with you , So kindly keep in touch with me right here < [email protected] > to enable us to know better , I will send you my Detail . also i have special something to discuss with you, hope to see your mail soon.
0
The problem for me with this sentence is that it talks about the hat, suit, and shoes. Typically, if I wanted to point out someone in the photo, I would choose *one* distinguishing characteristic and say, "He's the one wearing the black hat" (that is, no one else in the photo is wearing a black hat). It's a bit much to go on to the suit and shoes; it is not a natural sentence, in my opinion.
0
Ive read this text more than 4 times! Still it is confusing to me! Im the confusing student then! 😐
Haben Sie noch keine Antworten gefunden?
Geben Sie Ihre Fragen ein und lassen Sie sich von Muttersprachlern helfen!
Verpassen Sie nicht die Gelegenheit, bequem von zu Hause aus eine Sprache zu lernen. Stöbern Sie in unserer Auswahl an erfahrenen Sprachlehrern und melden Sie sich jetzt zu Ihrer ersten Unterrichtsstunde an!
Heute mit dem Lernen beginnen
