Emory
[ Grammar ] How to choose the right tense with “until” The simple present tense vs. the present perfect tense Don’t go outside until it _______ raining. A. has stopped B. stops C. Both are correct Q1: What is the answer and why? ---- Longman Dictionary says: Ref. https://reurl.cc/argklX You can also use the present perfect tense with until: @ The present perfect tense: S1: I will wait until I have heard from you. S2: Stir until the sugar has dissolved. @ The simple present tense : S3: I will wait until I “hear” from you. S4: Stir until the sugar “dissolves”. ------ Q2: I was wondering that if S3 and S4 are correct too? Q3: If S3 and S4 are correct, what is the difference between S1 (S2) and S3 (S4) ? Q4: Is the meaning between the simple present and the present perfect the same ? ----- Thanks a lot : )
13. Juni 2020 13:29
Antworten · 2
Dear Justine Marie, It's totally clear to me now. Your comprehensive explanation is quite useful. Thank you very much. ^__^
13. Juni 2020
In modern conversational English both are accepted. Until can be used with most tenses. Until marks a point in time when something will happen/stop happening. All sentences from S1-S4 are correct. S2 and S4 have quite similar meanings in conversation. The only small difference is that if you use Present Perfect the action has for sure been completed or perfected. "Stir until the sugar has dissolved would mean that the processes of dissolving is complete. (There is no sugar in solid form left, because the dissolution is total and complete) If you use "Stir well until the sugar dissolves" you are sure that the process of dissolution has started BUT you are unsure if it is complete (But in conversation this does not matter because dissolving sugar does not take too much time anyway so this difference becomes inconsequential and the meanings in these 2 sentences merge into the same thing.) This is the same with S1 and S3. There's really no great time difference between the time the subject 'starts to hear' from the object and when he 'finishes hearing' from him. And if there is it's probably just the amount of time he takes to read an email/message/ answer the phone that will prompt him to stop waiting. The differences between Simple present and present perfect can be seen in the other functions of the tenses. For example: I eat rice. (This is Simple present to denote a RECURRING TRUTH/FACT that has happened before, is true now and will happen again in the future.) I have eaten rice. (This is Present perfect used to denote an EXPERIENCE that has been perfected/completed in the past but is still true now)
13. Juni 2020
Haben Sie noch keine Antworten gefunden?
Geben Sie Ihre Fragen ein und lassen Sie sich von Muttersprachlern helfen!