Why is Simple Past used here over Present Perfect?
Yesterday I was watching a TV Show, and I saw a phrase that, according to grammar rules, is not quite correct. A man said, “He is the best tunneler I ever met,” however, I thought that we use Present Perfect with such adverbs as ever, so shouldn’t it have been said, “He is the best tunneler I’ve ever met?” Why is Past Simple used here over Present Perfect?
Wählen Sie aus verschiedenen Englisch Lehrkräften für ...
Antworten · 3
1
As the other members have already pointed out, the most likely explanation is simply that the speaker is using American English. In American English, it is common to come across examples of the past simple being used with adverbs indicating unfinished periods of time.
However, even in standard, correct English, "The best tunneler I ever met" is not a mistake. The past simple is correct, but it is used in a different context from the present perfect.
If you say "He is the best tunneller I've ever met" (GB spelling), this is an unfinished time period: the word 'ever' means 'at any time in my life up to now'. From this use of the present perfect, we understand that the speaker is still in a context where he meets tunnellers. The implication is that the man in question is the best tunneller he has met SO FAR. The present perfect is used for contexts which are still 'open' in some way: here, we understand that the speaker has not ruled out the possibility that he might one day meet a tunneller who is even better than this one.
If a speaker of standard English were to say "He is the best tunneller I ever met", this would refer to a 'closed' time period. Here, the meaning of 'ever' is 'during that whole period [when I worked with tunnellers]'. Let's say the speaker used to work in a profession where he met tunnellers, but he is now retired: he no longer meets tunnellers, so the situation is not likely to change. This is a perfectly valid use of the past simple.
I hope that helps. Please ask if there's anything else you'd like to know.
0
You are quite right about the rules. But the actor is using normal, everyday speech.
Perhaps I might suggest that you stand at a crossroads.
English comes in many forms or flavours. English speaking children learn the English spoken around them. This could be any variant, with any relationship to formal grammar. Later, they have to learn the official, formal "standard English" that you are probably seeing in your grammar books and learning from your teachers. You may see similar divergence between official Russian and street Russian ? I don't know. (And I've never quite grasped how close or how separate Russian and Ukrainian actually are ...?)
For some, these two language variants are closely aligned, but for very many they are quite different.
In popular culture and in everyday conversations you will hear all kinds of usages quite "forbidden" in the grammar books. Perhaps sadly for adult learners, many English speakers regard those rules as not really applying to us. They are just for when you have to read or write official forms. Of course there are many other English speakers who hate the informal and other variants of the language (their language), and want to call out all errors and "correct" the people who use them. Among native speakers this rarely ends well. But adult learners are a soft target.
So, to come back to your crossroads.
Down one path, you can master the formal rules as you are taught and learn them, and learn to use them well. And you can regard every deviation as an error, and every deviant user as a miscreant. Down this path lies pedantry - and plenty of company. There are many learners on italki on this pathway.
Down the other path, you can also master the formal rules and learn to use them well. But then you can recognise that fluent and well educated native speakers often don't use that language, and that there is another challenge in learning how they speak and write, and learning how to use either form as needed :) :)
0
It may be that the speaker was an American, I think they have different rules regarding the perfect tense!
Haben Sie noch keine Antworten gefunden?
Geben Sie Ihre Fragen ein und lassen Sie sich von Muttersprachlern helfen!
Verpassen Sie nicht die Gelegenheit, bequem von zu Hause aus eine Sprache zu lernen. Stöbern Sie in unserer Auswahl an erfahrenen Sprachlehrern und melden Sie sich jetzt zu Ihrer ersten Unterrichtsstunde an!
Heute mit dem Lernen beginnen
