Can I use both ... as well as?
Me and my colleague translated two similar texts from Czech into English.
We have two different opinions on the following:
1) František Pospíšil (1885–1958), a noted ethnologist from Brno, was one of the scholars
whose research aims and interpretations of the topics which he studied were determined both
by his individual interests as well as by social context.

2) The paper demonstrates how the research direction and the interpretation of researched topics can be determined by both individual interests and social context. František Pospíšil (1885–1958), a noted ethnologist from Brno, ........

I am not sure about using both .... as well as. Can you give me an advice?
Thank you , Zdenka

Question

Can I use both ... as well as?
Me and my colleague translated two similar texts from Czech into English.
We have two different opinions on the following: 
1) František Pospíšil (1885–1958), a noted ethnologist from Brno, was one of the scholars
whose research aims and interpretations of the topics which he studied were determined both
by his individual interests as well as by social context.

2) The paper demonstrates how the research direction and the interpretation of researched topics can be determined by both individual interests and social context. František Pospíšil (1885–1958), a noted ethnologist from Brno, ........

I am not sure about using both .... as well as. Can you give me an advice? 
Thank you , Zdenka

Answer

I like number 1 better. It’s clearer and gets immediately to the point. You could use the second, but I think the first is better.

Answer

No, you cannot use both constructions in the same sentence, it's redundant because they mean exactly the same thing. It's either "Both A and B" or "A as well as B".

Answer

both   ...  as well as... is possible, however, it is considered more polite to say "My colleague and I.....

Antworten · 5

Haben Sie noch keine Antworten gefunden?

Verpassen Sie nicht die Gelegenheit, bequem von zu Hause aus eine Sprache zu lernen. Stöbern Sie in unserer Auswahl an erfahrenen Sprachlehrern und melden Sie sich jetzt zu Ihrer ersten Unterrichtsstunde an!