what do you think of Sochi Olympic slogan "Hot. Cool. Yours"?
Sochi officials chose "Hot. Cool. Yours" as the official English version (I don’t use here the word ‘translation’ intentionally, as slogans are not a subject of translation but of ‘transcreation’) of the Russian slogan "Жаркие. Зимние. Твои". Apparently, foreign media (e.g. <a href="http://content.usatoday.com/communities/gameon/post/2012/09/Sochi-releases-Olympic-slogan-that-is-neither-hot-nor-cool-70001112/sochi-olympic-slogan-hot-cool-yours/70001112/1">http://content.usatoday.com/communities/gameon/post/2012/09/Sochi-releases-Olympic-slogan-that-is-neither-hot-nor-cool-70001112/sochi-olympic-slogan-hot-cool-yours/70001112/1</a> ) didn't like the English version that much, and some of them offer literal translation like “Warm. Wintry. Yours.”
I don’t like it, as the wordplay, which both the slogans had, was lost. Russian word жаркие (zharkie) along with its temperature meaning (‘warm’ - as we have o.games in one of the the warmest regions of our country) has meanings of ‘hot/heated’ as battle or argument can be (and competitions, maybe?), and ‘passionate’. Maybe I’m just not so good in English, but I don’t perceive ‘warm’ like that. Next they offer ‘wintry’ for зимние (zimnie), and it has the same meaning, but I like here ‘cool’ from the official version more as it’s not only about the temperature. And ‘Yours’ for твои (tvoi) some people (native English speaker) consider as grammatically incorrect.
We had a discussion with my collegues about that, so, as a Russian native speaker, I'd like you to answer some questions:
-Is the slogan grammatically correct? Some Americans said that "Yours" by utself sounds a little weird.
-Do you perceive it as a correct English phrase or is it more like "I understand it, but I'd say it differently"?
-Is the wordplay (and a message in a whole) clear?
I'd like to hear the answers from non-native speakers as well. Thank you
Have you watched it? How did you like it? Were the characters and representations clear for you? What did you like most?
Американец, живущий в России, делится впечатлениями. Обо всем.
Особенно впечатляет цикл "Война слов" :)
http://www.youtube.com/user/tkirby3679?feature=watch
Я, конечно, может чего-то не понимаю в местных порядках, но, товарищи мои русскоговорящие земляки и не очень... зачем вы учите людей плохому русскому? Ваши исправления в блокнотных записях нуждаются в повторных исправлениях.
