Cerca tra vari insegnanti di Inglese...
Alex G
Could anyone help me with the following question?
“They went out together for seven months before he proposed to her in 1961.”
Why is it used “went out together” instead of “had gone out together”? Hasn’t the action represented in “went out together” completed before “he proposed”?
8 giu 2025 18:03
Risposte · 7
1
Past perfect isn't necessary because the events are stated in the order in which they occurred.
8 giu 2025 21:27
1
Yes, the action was completed before he proposed. However, the word "before" establishes that all by itself. You CAN say
“They had gone out together for seven months before he proposed".
That would be correct but it feels repetitious because there is no need to emphasize the completed action by saying both "before" and "had gone".
You could also say
"They had gone out together for seven months WHEN he proposed to her"
because at that time they had the experience of going out for seven months. That would not be repetitious because "when" does not imply the action had been completed. Another possibility is
"They had been going out together for seven months when..."
8 giu 2025 18:48
Questo contenuto viola le linee guida della Comunità.
9 giu 2025 03:01
Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?
Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!
Alex G
Competenze linguistiche
Arabo, Arabo (egiziano), Inglese, Russo, Spagnolo
Lingua di apprendimento
Altri articoli che potrebbero piacerti

Same Word, Different Meaning: American, British, and South African English
21 consensi · 17 Commenti

How to Sound Confident in English (Even When You’re Nervous)
15 consensi · 12 Commenti

Marketing Vocabulary and Phrases for Business English Learners
13 consensi · 6 Commenti
Altri articoli
