Cerca tra vari insegnanti di Inglese...
Nancy Tejedor
Hi italki community
What option is the correct one?
1. Why were so many children working in the streets?
2. Why so many children were working in the streets?
I actually listened that phrase on a speech
Actually she said: "So I decided to study the reasons why children were working in the streets or why some children were being recruited by violent organizations, why were so many children suffering from chronic malnutrition"
So I didn't really get it why she uses both
Thanks in advance
19 gen 2024 02:17
Risposte · 7
1
#2 can be fixed in many ways:
"Why is it that so many children were working in the streets?"
"Why? So many children were working in the streets."
"So many children were working in the streets. Why?"
#1 is good.
19 gennaio 2024
1
I think she said it that way because sometimes people aren't precise with grammar, especially in spoken language. She really has two separate sentences there, joined by a comma splice, and the sentences have different word order.
1. "I decided to study the reasons why children were working in the streets or [I think she really means "and"] why some children were being recruited by violent organizations." This is a declaratory sentence with one dependent clause in active voice (subject precedes verb) and one in passive (subject of the sentence is object of verb and precedes it.)
2. "Why were so many children suffering from chronic malnutrition?" This is actually a question, so the verb comes first.
I hope that helps!
19 gennaio 2024
1
I think the second sentence is the correct oneđ
19 gennaio 2024
1
I'm not sure of the exact explanation, but:
1 Is a completely normal/correct question.
2. Is not a normal/correct question, and possibly not even a complete sentence all by itself. However it would be totally normal/correct if proceeded by a clause such as:
She wanted to know why so many children were working in the street.
So, to summarize/rephrase: 1 is a questions; 2 is a clause and could be part of a question, but is not a correct question by itself.
19 gennaio 2024
Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?
Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!
Nancy Tejedor
Competenze linguistiche
Inglese, Lingua dei segni messicana (LSM), Spagnolo
Lingua di apprendimento
Inglese, Lingua dei segni messicana (LSM)
Altri articoli che potrebbero piacerti

Santa, St. Nicholas, or Father Christmas? How Christmas Varies Across English-Speaking Countries
3 consensi · 0 Commenti

Reflecting on Your Progress: Year-End Language Journal Prompts
2 consensi · 1 Commenti

Same Word, Different Meaning: American, British, and South African English
25 consensi · 17 Commenti
Altri articoli
