Cerca tra vari insegnanti di Inglese...
Hong Kong SAR China flagdaiyu bao
Use of past perfect in this sentence?

Hello everyone

We often read in novels how a seemingly respectable person or family has some terrible secret which has been concealed from strangers for years. The English language possesses a vivid saying to describe this sort of situation. The terrible secret is called ‘a skeleton in the cupboard’. At some dramatic moment in the story, the terrible secret becomes known and a reputation is ruined. The reader’s hair stands on end when he reads in the final pages of the novel that the heroine a dear old lady who had always been so kind to everybody, had, in her youth, poisoned every one of her five husbands.


---------------

This is from a passage in the book New Concept English by British educator L. G. Alexander. 
I am confused by the use of past perfect used in the last sentence where I just highlightened. And this is what I have surmised:

Past perfect is used in 'a dear old lady who had always been so kind to everybody' because the author is citing the plot in a book, so past tense is needed. And the fact 'being always so kind to everybody' occured in the past and over a time span, so past perfect 'had always been so kind to everybody' is used here to indicate a state in the past.


The second past perfect is used in 'had, in her youth, poisoned every one of her five husbands' because her murder, according to the reader's view, occured in a time anterior to where reader have just read, so past perfect is used to indicate a time even before the past event.

Am I right to think so? Could you please kindly share your opinions? And I'll be very grateful for your help.

Commenti · 2

1

Your analysis is correct for the quoted text.



0
Thank you, Chris!

Non perdere l'opportunità di imparare una lingua comodamente da casa tua. Esplora la nostra selezione di insegnanti di lingue esperti e iscriviti subito alla tua prima lezione!

Inizia a imparare oggi