Abstract to an article
Considerations on evidence have mostly been focused on how truth can be achieved within the legal procedure, polarized in two positions that accept the so-called "real truth" and those that deny this perspective and present a formal or procedural truth as a counterpoint. Nevertheless, it is necessary to go beyond the subject of truth in the context of a legal process, since the evidential materials do not constitute facts per se, capable of proofing the truth of things. Proof is always an inferential reasoning (abduction) that conjectures about an absent past whose hypothesis can not be verified. Accordingly, it is based on this premise that the author analyzes how the formation process of evidence occurs, as inferential reasoning, and what its reasonable limits. Thus, based on the fact that all evidence is circumstantial, in the sense that it only refers to a determinate agent through an abductive process, it takes advantage of the interpretative limits delineated by Umberto Eco in the book The Limits of Interpretation, to conclude that a given proof, that is, an inferential reasoning about the elements discovered (marks, symptoms and clues), can be considered reasonable or not, according to the abductive creativity of the conclusions presented. Consequently, given the impossibility of subsequent verification, only reasonable justifications must be acceptable in the probationary field, on penalty of misapplication of the law. inventional judgments that abuse of the meta-abuctive process must be reviewed by the courts in order to ensure a reasonable application of rule to facts.
Cerca tra vari insegnanti di Inglese...
Correzioni · 2
1
Abstract to an article
Considerations on evidence have mostly been focused on how truth can be achieved within the legal process procedure, polarized in two positions that accept the so-called "real truth" and those that deny this perspective and present a formal or procedural truth as a counterpoint. Nevertheless, it is necessary to go beyond the subject of truth in the context of a legal process, since the evidential materials do not constitute facts per se, capable of proving the truth of things. Proof is always based on inferential reasoning (abduction) that conjectures about an absent past whose hypothesis can not be verified. Accordingly, it is based on this premise that the author analyzes how the formation process of evidence occurs, as inferential reasoning, and what its reasonable limits. Thus, based on the fact that all evidence is circumstantial, in the sense that it only refers to a determinate agent through an abductive process, it takes advantage of the interpretative limits delineated by Umberto Eco in the book The Limits of Interpretation, to conclude that a given proof, that is, an inferential reasoning about the elements discovered (marks, symptoms and clues), can be considered reasonable or not, according to the abductive creativity of the conclusions presented. Consequently, given the impossibility of subsequent verification, only reasonable justifications must be acceptable in the probationary field, on penalty of misapplication of the law. conventional judgments that abuse of the meta-abuctive process must be reviewed by the courts in order to ensure that a reasonable application of rule is based on facts.Vuoi progredire più velocemente?
Unisciti a questa comunità di apprendimento e prova gli esercizi gratuiti!
Non perdere l'opportunità di imparare una lingua comodamente da casa tua. Esplora la nostra selezione di insegnanti di lingue esperti e iscriviti subito alla tua prima lezione!
Inizia a imparare oggi
