Ryota
Is the clause “without whose … life” an adjectival phrase that modify “other animals”? “Are other animals disappearing that at first do not seem to be essential yet without whose activity we could not conceive life?”
27 mar 2024 06:30
Risposte · 3
2
This sentence could be written as "Are other animals that do not seem essential and that without whose activity we could not conceive life disappearing?" but this violates English end-weight principles. If you want more information, do a net search for "Definition and Examples of End Weight in Grammar." The article on the thoughtco dot com web site is meant for a general audience.
27 marzo 2024
INVITATO
Salaam Ryota! Yes, "whose" refers to the "animals".
27 marzo 2024
It is a badly placed adjective phrase. To make your sentences clear, place adjectival phrases next to the words they are intended to modify: “Are animals, without whose activity life could not be conceived, disappearing?”
27 marzo 2024
Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?
Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!