Ei Shwe Zin
Tom came down with flu while/as/when we were on holiday. Which is the best answer?
30 lug 2022 07:16
Risposte · 9
1
Probably "while", to emphasize that the holiday (US "vacation") lasted for a while. We could also use "when". With a verb of state, the word "as" would tend to imply a causal relationship, i.e., being on holiday caused Tom to come down with the flu. If we used an inceptive verb with a more perfective aspect, for example "Tom came down with the flu as we began our holiday", that would work quite well with "as" (meaning at the time), or we could use "when". "While" would not work well for such a verb / aspect.
30 luglio 2022
To my knowledge,all the alternatives are fine because my Grammar book says" we can use as, when and while to mean "during the time that". What do you think of it?
30 luglio 2022
I agree with Phil. WHILE or WHEN but maybe AS will work. What about "Tom came down with flu as we were on holiday," meaning that Tom is an annoying person who always gets ill at the start of something! "Tom didn't get out of bed as we were on holiday." Yeah?
30 luglio 2022
While
30 luglio 2022
Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?
Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!