questions about "can have been" and "can be " "was"and “is".
First,please help me finish the following^^
Jack:My brother has no__________(A:hat B: hats) himself.
Jim:oh,but I saw him wearing a nice hat yesterday,whose___(A:was B: is) it?
Jack:It must______(A:have been B:be) mine.
Jim:______(A:was B:is) your new hat?
Jack:Well,it can't__________(A:have been B:be) my new one.My new hat is in my room right now,so is must______(A:have been B:be) my old one.
Well...I can see the difference between "He can't have been reading."and "He can't be reading now." ,but such as
"She can't have been Japanese,she must have been Chinese" really troubles me.Why not just say "She can't be Japanese,she must be Chinese."
A:Did we ever meet a Japanese girl at the yeaterday party?
B:That girl wearing yellow dress may have been Japanese.(Why not just say:"That girl wearing yellow dress may be Japanese.")
C:And the one who weared a strange black shirt_____(A:was B:is) Japanese.
another:
A:Sir,I am afraid the one who killed your brother is......you know..maybe Jack.
B:No! The murderer can't______(A:have been B:be C:both is ok) Jack! He can't be! Jack is my best friend! How ____(A:was B:is) Jack the murderer?
I am not sure if the last sentence I wrote makes sence or have any grammatical problem.please help me get it right,thanks!!!
Thanks for coming here! All the sentences here were written by me.If any of them sounds strange or just doesn't really make sence,point it out please^ ^
Cerca tra vari insegnanti di Inglese...
Risposte · 6
0
Jack: My brother has no HATS himself.
Jim: Oh, but I saw him wearing a nice hat yesterday. Whose WAS it?
Jack: It must HAVE BEEN mine.
Jim: WAS IT your new hat?
Jack: Well, it can't HAVE BEEN my new one. My new hat is in my room right now, so is must HAVE BEEN my old one.
Well...I can see the difference between "He can't have been reading." and "He can't be reading now." ,but such as
"She can't have been Japanese, she must have been Chinese" really troubles me. Why not just say "She can't be Japanese, she must be Chinese."
She can’t have been may refer to someone who is dead, whereas she can’t be is definitely someone still alive! But also, if you don’t expect to ever meet her again, you would probably use can’t have been, but if you expect to meet her again, you wold be more likely to use can’t be. It’s about how final the past is – is it still connected to the present in some way?
A: Did we ever meet a Japanese girl at the party yesterday?
B: That girl wearing yellow dress may have been Japanese. (Why not just say: "That girl wearing yellow dress may be Japanese.") - because she isn’t here now, and probably isn’t wearing the same dress anymore!
C: And the one who wore a strange black shirt WAS Japanese.
Another:
A:Sir,I am afraid the one who killed your brother is......you know…maybe Jack.
B: No! The murderer can't C (A: have been B: be C: both are OK) Jack! He can't be! Jack is my best friend! How ____(A: was B: is) Jack the murderer? How could Jack have been the murderer?
I am not sure if the last sentence I wrote makes senSe or haS any grammatical problemS. Please help me get it right,thanks!!!
Thanks for coming here! All the sentences here were written by me. If any of them sound strange or just really DON’T make senSe, please point it out.
I have made a few other corrections to your text too. After punctuation marks (,:, “) you need a space before the next word, just as you would without them.
0
Jack:My brother has no hat for himself. - My brother doesn't own any hat.
Jim:oh,but I saw him wearing a nice hat yesterday,whose____(A:was B: is) it? B
Jack:It must______(A:have been B:be) mine. B
Jim:______(A:was B:is) your new hat? -- Was it your new hat?
Jack:Well,it can't____B______(A:have been B:be) my new one.My new hat is in my room right now,so is must___B___(A:have been B:be) my old one.
Well...I can see the difference between "He can't have been reading."and "He can't be reading now." ,but such as
"She can't have been Japanese,she must have been Chinese" really troubles me.Why not just say "She can't be Japanese,she must be Chinese." -- You're correct. Besides, the first sentence doesn't make any sense.
A:Did we ever meet a Japanese girl at the yeaterday party? -- Did we meet a Japanese girl at the party yesterday?
B:That girl wearing yellow dress may have been Japanese.(Why not just say:"That girl wearing yellow dress may be Japanese.") -- That girl wearing a yellow dress looks like a Japanese.
C:And the one who weared a strange black shirt_____(A:was B:is) Japanese. -- And the one who's wearing a strange black shirt is a Japanese.
another:
A:Sir,I am afraid the one who killed your brother is......you know..maybe Jack. -- Sir, I'm afraid that the one who killed your brother is... you know... maybe Jack.
B:No! The murderer can't___B___(A:have been B:be C:both is ok) Jack! He can't be! Jack is my best friend! How ____(A:was B:is) Jack the murderer? - How did Jack became the murderer?
I am not sure if the last sentence I wrote makes sence or have any grammatical problem.please help me get it right,thanks!!!
Thanks for coming here! All the sentences here were written by me.If any of them sounds strange or just doesn't really make sence,point it out please^ ^
0
I am not expert of this language. Still, providing you with this information to offer some help to you. Hope, you find this helpful.
Jack:My brother has no hat for himself.
Jim:oh,but I saw him wearing a nice hat yesterday,whose was it? Past tense - was.
Jack:It must have been mine.
Jim: Was it your new hat?
Jack:Well,it can't be my new one.(couldn't be can be used too). My new hat is in my room right now,so it must have been my old one.
"He can't have been reading." This sentence is not correct. That is what I think.
"He can't be reading now." This is correct.
"She can't have been Japanese. Again, this sentence is not correct in my opinion.
she must have been Chinese" really troubles me.Why not just say "She can't be Japanese,she must be Chinese."
A:Did we ever meet a Japanese girl at the yesterday party? (Here you cannot use "ever" as you are referring to a particular party)
B:That girl wearing yellow dress may have been Japanese.(Why not just say:"That girl wearing yellow dress may be Japanese.") You can say "She may be Japanese." If you are almost sure or strongly feel that, then you can say "She must have been Japanese" as you find something that supports your observation.
C:And the one who wore a strange black shirt was Japanese. Wore -past tense, so 'was" is correct here.
another:
A:Sir,I am afraid the one who killed your brother is......you know..maybe Jack.
B:No! The murderer can't be Jack! He just can't be! Jack is my best friend! How can he be the murderer?
I am not sure if the last sentence I wrote makes sense or have any grammatical problem.please help me get it right,thanks!!!
Thanks for coming here! All the sentences here were written by me.If any of them sounds strange or just doesn't really make sence,point it out please^ ^
Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?
Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!
Non perdere l'opportunità di imparare una lingua comodamente da casa tua. Esplora la nostra selezione di insegnanti di lingue esperti e iscriviti subito alla tua prima lezione!
Inizia a imparare oggi
