A grammar question in AP News
"And it's a rare sight during a Chicago winter. But this hummingbird which showed up just before Thanksgiving is attracting a bit of a following. The birds stayed for 7 weeks before apparently heading south for the winter. "
In the last sentence, why is it "the birds stayed for 7 weeks before"? Not "the birds stayed since 7 weeks before" or "the birds has stayed 7 weeks before"?
Because I thought that I shouldn't put "for" behind a past simple tense.
So is there any grammar knowledge here?
And here's another question: does the last sentence mean the birds have stayed for 7 weeks and it shows the winter is coming?
You can watch the video here : http://bit.ly/zD8TGx .
Thanks!Sorry, I should ask:
Why is it "the birds stayed for 7 weeks before"? Not "the birds stayed since 7 weeks ago" or "the birds has stayed 7 weeks"?
OK.. REALLY sorry for my mistakes...
I should ask:
Why is it "the birds stayed for 7 weeks before"? Not "the birds stayed 7 weeks ago" or "the birds has stayed since the last 7 weeks"?
Cerca tra vari insegnanti di Inglese...
Risposte · 3
0
This is how you divide up the sentence:
"The birds stayed / for 7 weeks / before apparently heading south / for the winter." Pretty clear! :)
0
Here's a very easy rule that will make this clear: when you have a COUNTING number, use "for." So in your example, "7 weeks" has a counting number of "7"--if you said, "since December" or "since last week" or "since 1972," you would not have a counting number, so you use "since" (1972 is a number, but it's a date, not a counting number).
0
我想是需要一个介词来引导时间,比如7点去学校,go to school at 7 a.m.
而for是一个表示时间持续的介词。 光有一个时间不能在句子中间发生关系吧。
第一个意思应该是‘鸟之前在这里停留了7个礼拜’,而后一句是,鸟在7个礼拜之前停在这里。
注意,这两句表达的意思不同哦。
第三句应该也要加for。来配合stay表达时间。为什么用for,因为你用别的单词不对嘛,比如说at,in,after,再说和句子表达的意思不一样。for是最好的
Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?
Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!
Non perdere l'opportunità di imparare una lingua comodamente da casa tua. Esplora la nostra selezione di insegnanti di lingue esperti e iscriviti subito alla tua prima lezione!
Inizia a imparare oggi
