Cerca tra vari insegnanti di Inglese...
Russia flagNatalya
Using the phrasal verb "to pick up" There is two examples containing this phrasal verb: 1) We drove to the airport the next morning to pick up Susan 2) I picked her up at Covent Garden to take her to lunch with my mother In the second sentence there is the construction "verb + pronoun + preposition", but in the first sentence the order of words is different from one in the second sentence. What is the reason? If I wrote "I picked up her at Coven Garden ..." would it be correct?

Risposte · 7

3
As far as I recall the rules, if you use "me/you/him/her/us/them" (ie. object personal pronoun) with a phrasal verb that allows this pattern, you always put it in the middle, never outside. However, you can also write "I picked Susan up at Covent Garden." Your choice of "her" isn't a good example, as "her" is also possessive. "I picked up her..." Picked up her what? Picked up her brother?
1
There are two examples containing this phrasal verb: 1) We drove to the airport the next morning to pick up Susan 2) I picked her up at Covent Garden to take her to lunch with my mother Your own sentence is not correct. You would have to say "I picked Susan up at Covent Garden". If you were to use the pronoun, you would say "I picked her up". You could say "I picked up her suitcase and other luggage at the airport". "I picked up her Mother". But this is correct: "I picked her up".
1
Peachy's knowledge of the mechanics and rules of grammar, sh*ts all over mine - I have no understanding of the rules what so ever. Well a small understanding. But both of your sentences are correct. To pick someone up and "I picked someone up". I think sometimes it's easier to understand common sentences like this, and memorise them. Pick her up on Monday morning and drop her off on Friday. I suppose, "drop her off" is another phrasal verb? I'm learning too :) Like Peachey said, there's only one way that sentence would work, if you think of the combinations. You can't say, "Picked up her" or "picked up she" - oooooooooooooh the water's rising up to my eyes hehehe
0
1. to pick up Susan / to pick her up 2. picked her up / picked Susan up 3. picked up her (INCORRECT) Rule for separable phrasal verbs: "When the direct object is a pronoun, however, the particle [preposition] must be separated from the verb" (Hacker, p. 247). By the way, everyone knows "to pick up" means "to meet and transport by CAR," right? Because before I went to Tokyo to teach English, I received an e-mail saying someone would pick me up at the airport and show me my new home. What actually happened: I was met at the airport by a representative who said I had to buy my own TRAIN ticket. She would show me how to take the TRAIN to my new apartment. I had two large suitcases, which I hadn't thought would be a problem because I was told that I would be "picked up." After multiple transfers and multiple stairways and a long walk from the final stop, I finally reached my new home totally exhausted (and a little bit angry). So, please, use phrasal verbs correctly...
0
This is a standard rule regarding phrasal verbs that everybody has to learn.

Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?

Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!

Non perdere l'opportunità di imparare una lingua comodamente da casa tua. Esplora la nostra selezione di insegnanti di lingue esperti e iscriviti subito alla tua prima lezione!

Inizia a imparare oggi