anu
This is she/her. It's they/them. When would you use This is she/her.? I know that these two versions are sometimes interchangeable, but people tend to use 'This is her.' rather thatn 'This is she' I have the same questions about 'It's they/them.'
25 giu 2012 09:20
Risposte · 10
4
If a person is a student, then he or she must pay attention to the strictly formal grammar. Strictly speaking, "this is she" and "it is they" is correct grammar. However, people often use the objective case pronouns, her and them, especially when speaking.
25 giugno 2012
2
I can't formally explain the grammar, but you will probably never be wrong if you use 'This is her' and 'This is them', but you would almost never use 'This is she' or even more so 'This is they.' In each of these instances you would probably clarify the subject and object by saying 'She is the one' or 'These are the ones...' 'This is she' and 'These are they' may be technically correct, but you should simply avoid there use. In my 50+ years of speaking English as a native, I've probably used those phrases once or twice and only in some formal, literary contest. Hope that helps.... Erik
25 giugno 2012
maybe for example: this is her ball. but the ball is hers.
25 giugno 2012
Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?
Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!