Where is the subject?
Hi, i need assistance with following sentence:
从埃及来的人说阿拉伯语
please advise which translation is closer to original?
- Men, came from Egypt, speak Arabic
- Egyptians speak Arabic.
or both can be used depending on situation?
Also i would like to know if subject of this sentence is 人 or 埃及来的人.
Thank you
Cerca tra vari insegnanti di Inglese...
Risposte · 5
1
我有不一樣的理解
Egyptians speak Arabic.
=> 埃及人說阿拉伯語
=> 這是單純的敘述
The men, who came from Egypt, speak Arabic
=> 這些人, 來自埃及, 說阿拉伯語
=> 這些人說阿拉伯語 , 這些人來自埃及
=> 補充說明這些人的來歷
The men who came from Egypt speak Arabic
=> 這些來自埃及的人說阿拉伯語
=> 這些人的來歷已經被限定了
中文 從埃及來的人說阿拉伯語 應與
The men who came from Egypt speak Arabic 相近
Where is the subject?
與英語句子相同.
0
从 埃及 来 的 人 说 阿拉伯语 = People from Egypt speak Arabic
both Chinese and English sentences are pretty unnatural
in Chinese that would be
埃及人 说 阿拉伯语
or
在 埃及 讲 的 语言 是 阿拉伯语
the simple subject is 人
the extended subject is 从埃及来的人
0
I fully agree with Randy. The first English sentence is totally unnatural. As for the Chinese sentence, it sounds as though it is a direct translation of the following English sentence: "People from Egypt speak Arabic". That being said, I think "Egyptians speak Arabic" is a correct rendering.
0
Say "Egyptians speak Arabic". The other way is too awkward.
0
- Men, came from Egypt, speak Arabic
This is closer,I think.
The subject is "人". You can also believe that " 从埃及来的人" is the subject. It's all right."从埃及来的"is to qualify "人".
Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?
Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!
Non perdere l'opportunità di imparare una lingua comodamente da casa tua. Esplora la nostra selezione di insegnanti di lingue esperti e iscriviti subito alla tua prima lezione!
Inizia a imparare oggi
