Philip
Is haber ever used to mean possess? I know we say "Tengo una manzana" but are there any exceptions where you'd use haber instead?
17 set 2014 16:48
Risposte · 7
In spanish "haber" y "tener" son verbos distintos. Cuando hablas de posesión, nunca utilices haber. When you talk about possession, never "haber". Cuando hablas de un deber, en algunos casos se puede emplear haber. When you talk about obligation, sometimes you can use "haber". Less common. Ejemplo: Tengo muchos problemas. (Nunca haber) Tengo que irme. También posible: He de irme. Quizás con haber denota menos fuerza en la obligación. Maybe with "haber" shows a weak obligation.
17 settembre 2014
No, they're not interchangeable. Tengo una manzana = I have an apple. Hay una manzana = There is an apple. If you change 'have' for 'to be', then the concept looses its belonging relationship. REF.: I'm a Certified Spanish Teacher
17 settembre 2014
"Tengo" is similar to To have." "Haber" is more near to impersonal form "there is", "There are"... , usually "haber" is a auxiliar verb, and we use to made the past, "Yo he tendio". But some time we use this alone, "Habia una manzana", "Hay una manzana", in this form never use subject.
17 settembre 2014
Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?
Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!