Cerca tra vari insegnanti di Inglese...
Jordan flagem king
Help me Which is better ??? Have you seen a friend or Did you see a friend ? where i can use each one ?

Risposte · 2

1
It doesn't really make sense to say "a friend" in these examples. a/an are "indefinite articles". They're not specific. You need to be specific and use "definite articles" such as THE friend or THAT friend. You could even say "my friend" if you want. If you want to know the difference between have you seen/did you see, then here's the explanation: "Have you seen my friend?" could mean have you EVER seen my friend before? Or it could also mean have you seen my friend RECENTLY? "Did you see my friend?" is asking if you saw that friend before at a specific point in time. Examples: "Did you see my friend a few minutes ago?" "Did you see my friend last week?" let me know if my reply didn't answer your question :)
0
Neither is better than the other, they are two different verb tenses. 1. did + [past tense] = simple past >> Use this for actions that started and ended in the past. - I saw a friend yesterday. = I did see a friend yesterday. - I ate dinner last night. = I did eat dinner last night. - You drove to work this morning. = You did drive to work this morning. - He said "thank you" to his mother. = He did say "thank you" to his mother. A. Using the "did" form emphasizes that the action *really* happened, otherwise the meanings are identical. B. The "did" form is _required_ to form a question in the simple past: - Did you see a friend today? - Did you eat dinner last night? - Did you drive to work this morning? - Did he say "thank you" to his mother? 2. have + [past participle] = present perfect >> Use this for actions that started in the past but continue into, or have results in, the present. - I have seen a friend today. (grammatically correct, but the meaning is odd) - I have eaten dinner. - You have driven to work today. - He has said "thank you" to his mother. A. This tense is rather difficult to explain. B. The question is formed by moving the words around: - Have you seen a friend today? - etc.

Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?

Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!

Non perdere l'opportunità di imparare una lingua comodamente da casa tua. Esplora la nostra selezione di insegnanti di lingue esperti e iscriviti subito alla tua prima lezione!

Inizia a imparare oggi