The difference between "90% of the +noun/90% of +noun/90% +noun."
I wrote in my notebook entry that "In Zootopia, 90% of its/the citizens are dominated by grazers."
I wondered if it was possible to use other structures as in the following sentences, without altering its meaning:
a. In Zootopia, 90% of citizens are dominated by grazers.
b. In Zootopia, 90% citizens are dominated by grazers.
Questions:
1. Comparing with "c.In Zootopia, 90% of the/its citizens are dominated by grazers", I think b=c.(Am I right?) At the same time, I think it is incorrect to write sentence (a) under this context, because "citizens" refer to people in Zootopia. Because it is not a general idea, I will need "the" before "citizens". Is it correct?
2. Using Google search, I do see people using "90% of +noun" structure a lot, e.g. "90% of People can't see what's wrong with this picture". Under this context, I think it is incorrect and unappropriate to write "90% of the people can't see...", because it doesn't confine "people" to a specific group. Am I right?
Thanks a lot!
Cerca tra vari insegnanti di Inglese...
Risposte · 9
1
Actually, sentence (b) is not grammatically correct in any context that I can think of, so (b) does not equal (c). When using percentages in this way, you must use the construction: 90% + of + (definite article/possessive adjective) + noun. The definite article and/or the possessive adjective is not required. You are correct that including the definite article "the" tends to narrow the scope to specific group, but since you already mention at the beginning that you are referring to Zootopia, both (a) & (c) have identical meaning in this case.
All of the following sentences have the same meaning and are interchangeable:
In Zootopia, 90% of citizens are dominated by grazers.
In Zootopia, 90% of the citizens are dominated by grazers.
90% of (the) citizens in Zootopia are dominated by grazers.
In Zootopia, 90% of its citizens are dominated by grazers.
(Note: you can only use "its" here because you have already mentioned that you are talking about Zootopia)
0
1. I think that it’s needed to put “of” in there, but it isn’t required for “the.” So for the sentences that you created, the first one, sentence a, would be correct.
2. Although usually, that wouldn’t make sense because the “people” aren’t specified, they are assuming we understand that 90% of people who see the picture don’t see what’s wrong. It’s a bit vague, but it works out somehow.
0
All of the other answers are great, but I wanted to add two more possibilities to the list.
Instead of:
In Zootopia, 90% of its citizens are dominated by grazers.
You could say more compactly/succintly:
1) 90% of Zootopia's citizens are dominated by grazers.
And you can even say:
2) 90% of Zootopia is dominated by grazers.
In this case, Zootopia is a singular object so it needs a singular verb "is".
0
a. In Zootopia, 90% of THE citizens are dominated by grazers.
I would add a 'the' before citizens as you suggested. The noun has to take an article in this case.
b. In Zootopia, 90% OF THE citizens are dominated by grazers.
People is a group so 90% of people would be right. But citizens cannot be used as a collective noun. Also, since you are talking about Zootopia in particular, when you say citizens it has to refer to Zootopia (citizens of Zootopia or 90% of the citizens [of Zootopia])
Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?
Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!
Non perdere l'opportunità di imparare una lingua comodamente da casa tua. Esplora la nostra selezione di insegnanti di lingue esperti e iscriviti subito alla tua prima lezione!
Inizia a imparare oggi
