Cerca tra vari insegnanti di Inglese...
South Korea flagSong, Jeung Hyeon
Is grammarly.com fraud? Following is a part of what grammarly.com proofread my text which cost me 7 usd. but not a single world has changed. Is it fraud or something? It is no doubt that Hemingway's gender portrayals in his novels are controversial and his equivocal stance on gender left the readers confused. Especially, whether the gender of a sea in his novels is male or female has been the most recurring controversial issue. In The Old Man and the Sea and Islands in the Streams, which share similar qualities with a sea setting, provide the reader substantial textual evidence by which we can examine Hemingway's idea on this issue specifically. Contrary to mainstream interpretations, I postulate that the sea's gender cannot be fixed because both protagonists, Santiago and Thomas Hudson in the novels, refer to the sea as both male and female to which I named it a 'dual-gendered' sea. According to the textual evidence, the gender of a sea shifts from male to female and vice versa depending on the ....

Risposte · 4

4
The text does not look like it has been proofed by a native-speaker. If it has been proofed, the person did not notice several glaring grammar mistakes and some other minor issues. You would probably have got a better result from Italki Notebook. Grammarly does not deserve any money for this effort. In fact, they should pay you for wasting your time and misleading you.
2
[]There[] is no doubt that Hemingway's gender portrayals in his novels are controversial and his equivocal stance on gender []leaves[] the readers confused. Especially, whether the gender of [the] sea in his novels is male or female has been the most recurring controversial issue. In "The Old Man and the Sea" and "Islands in the Streams", which share similar qualities [including] a sea setting, []the reader [is provided with] substantial textual evidence by which we can examine Hemingway's idea on this issue specifically. [I've corrected it minimally.]
1
I believe the site's strategy is to divide up a text and send it out to multiple proofreaders - who are likely to be from different varieties of English (British, American, etc.) - that revise their part and then return it to grammarly. This gets the job done fast and (technically) sticks to the idea that qualified people are revising the text. The problems created from this strategy have left many people to feel that the service falls short. Maybe that happened to you.
1
Your passage does require some corrections. For example, it should begin "There is no doubt..." not "It is no doubt." Also the verb "to leave," should probably be in the present tense in that sentence, not the simple past tense. You can draw your own conclusions as to whether the absence of corrections represents a mistake or something worse on their part.

Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?

Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!

Non perdere l'opportunità di imparare una lingua comodamente da casa tua. Esplora la nostra selezione di insegnanti di lingue esperti e iscriviti subito alla tua prima lezione!

Inizia a imparare oggi