kimconu
Are they the same meaning? Was he EVER a teacher? Was he ONCE a teacher? And can I answer that: No, he's never been a teacher.
6 mar 2019 08:59
Risposte · 3
1
If you say 'Was he once a teacher?', you mean 'He was a teacher at SOME point in his life, wasn't he?'. You suspect that this is true, and you are looking for a confirmation of this fact. Perhaps you have noticed how good he is at explaining things, so you presume that he has teaching experience. If you say 'Was he ever a teacher?', you mean 'Tell me if he has been a teacher at ANY time in his life'. This could mean that you have no idea, or it could mean that you suspect that he has never been a teacher: 'He has never been a teacher, has he?' You might like to take a look at the Discussion which I initiated yesterday (https://www.italki.com/discussion/199886), as it deals with the same issue. The difference between 'something' and 'anything' for objects is the same as the difference between 'once' and 'ever' for times.
6 marzo 2019
Yes, they both mean the same thing, and your answer to the question is perfect.
6 marzo 2019
In my opinion NO. Frequently "Ever" we use it with verbal tense: the present perfect, in question for example: "Have you ever been to France?" . I suggest to verify a Phrasal verb, Let's see others opinions here.
6 marzo 2019
Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?
Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!