Cerca tra vari insegnanti di Inglese...
Ukraine flagSashaInsegnante professionista
has kept or had kept dairy cattle "Because the direction of the wind and sunlight varied hugely in the different locations, the scientists were able to rule out weather and the position of the sun as an explanation. "We conclude that the magnetic field is the only common and most likely factor responsible for the observed alignment," the researchers wrote in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Gywn Jones, who (30)_____ kept dairy cattle for 25 years in West Sussex, confirmed: "They know what weather to expect in advance." 30 has or had I have no idea what to look at. There's the word 'confirmed', so it looks like I have to use 'had'. Having said this, I am not actually sure.

Risposte · 17

6
'Has kept' would mean that he still keeps cows. 'Had kept' would mean that he has stopped keeping cows. The Russian speakers on this page seem to be under the mistaken impression that the presence of a past simple means that the information about Mr Jones's experience needs to be in the past perfect. This is not the case. In fact, the tense of the verb 'confirmed' is irrelevant. The fact that he confirmed something yesterday (past tense) does NOT mean that that he stopped being a dairy farmer at that point! It's not entirely clear from the context, but, like the other native speakers, I think that 'has kept' is most likely. We have no reason to assume that Gwyn Jones no longer keeps cattle. He's being quoted as an expert on cows, so it's reasonable to presume that he is still in this profession. If the text said 'had kept', the readers would wonder whether there's some key information missing. We'd ask ourselves the question "What happened? When and why did he stop keeping cattle?". For example, in a text looking back to the BSE disease crisis of the 1990s, you might see the sentence 'Gwyn Jones had kept dairy cattle for 25 years [ until the crisis hit in the 1990s and he had to destroy all his livestock and change his profession]. In your text, however, there is nothing to suggest that he isn't still raising cattle. 'Has kept' would therefore be the normal, expected tense to see in this context.
4
Since he says “They know ....” the implication is that he still keeps dairy cattle, and “has” would be correct.
1
Actually I wonder if we are not looking at the wrong words to determine context and tense. To me, the fact that Gwen Jones says 'they' rather than 'we' gives us a clue. Gwen Jones is no longer part of the community of West Sussex, so, to me, the use of the word 'had' would be more appropriate to describe his past cattle ownership.in West Sussex. Still, we would need more of the context to be absolutely sure.
1
Had ( He had been keeping it for 25 years before he confirmed smth.)
1
This is really an unfair question as we do not know if this person was still keeping cows at the time that she made that statement. As a test question, it is most likely that she still is keeping them, but it is possible that she isn't. Obviously I would respond to the most likely choice "has" and try to forget how unfair and ridiculous the question is.

Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?

Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!

Non perdere l'opportunità di imparare una lingua comodamente da casa tua. Esplora la nostra selezione di insegnanti di lingue esperti e iscriviti subito alla tua prima lezione!

Inizia a imparare oggi