[ Grammar ] Absolute phrase
S1: Mark has three daughters, all of whom like classical music.
S2: Mark has three daughters, and all of them like classical music.
S3: Mark has three daughters, all of them liking classical music.
----
I know S1, S2, and S3 are grammatically correct.
However, I was wondering that why S3 seems to be unnatural to native speakers?
Thanks a lot : )
Cerca tra vari insegnanti di Inglese...
Risposte · 20
1
The construction in S3 is used only in a very specific context, one that implies "because".
Dave being a great fan of Ed Sheeran, I got an autograph after the concert and gave it to him later.
(i.e. I got him an autograph *because* he is a fan of Ed Sheeran)
The farmer has switched his crop this year, maize bringing in a greater profit than last year.
(i.e. the farmer has switched *because* of the greater profit)
Your example implies that Mark has three daughters *because* they all like classical music - which is clearly absurd.
1
In S3 "liking" sounds wrong.
This would be OK;
S4: Mark has three daughters, he finds that all of them are liking classical music as they mature.
1
You can't use LIKING in the third sentence because you need a verb in that position. Think about the basic grammar of English: Subject + VERB. You need a verb after the word THEY.
LIKING is the present participle (the -ing form) of LIKE. Usually, present participles/the -ing forms are used as verbs but not always.
They can also function as nouns.
LIKING CLASSICAL MUSIC is actually a NOUN phrase.
LIKING CLASSICAL MUSIC is a marker of good taste.
A liking for classical music is a marker of good taste.
0
Dear Jaclyn,
I googled it, and I just find a few examples. It's a tricky question. ^_^
Anyway, thank you : )
0
I don't know... it just sounds weird and no one says that...
Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?
Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!
Non perdere l'opportunità di imparare una lingua comodamente da casa tua. Esplora la nostra selezione di insegnanti di lingue esperti e iscriviti subito alla tua prima lezione!
Inizia a imparare oggi
