Laura asked their friends if they would come on Saturday or Sunday. (Need help with this sentence)
I just can't figure out why the following sentence expresses three possibilities/options.
Example:
Laura asked their friends IF they would come on Saturday OR Sunday.
It is said that in that sentence "IF" expresses three possibilities/options: come on Saturday, come on Sunday, or don’t come at all. But why is that so?
If I split the example sentence into two parts and I take the second part, I would have "IF they would come on Saturday or Sunday." Now I see the verb "come" followed by "on Saturday or Sunday." The conjunction "OR" is connecting two possibilities not three. Where does the third possibility/option arise from?
I hope that someone can help me with this.
Cerca tra vari insegnanti di Inglese...
Risposte · 6
1
For me, my initial reaction is that it is indeed a two-option question - saturday OR sunday. "Are you coming on saturday or sunday?" does not at all sound like there is an implied 3rd option of "not at all".
however, to really make a two option question really clear, we could use "either". "LAura asked her friends if they would come on EITHER saturday or sunday". This would be an unequivocal two-option statement. I still struggle to interpret the given statement as a three-option query. But that's just me!
0
This is how you quote.
Imagine Laura was asking her students and you were there. Now you are telling me that she asked which day will the students come.
So this is how you quote: "She sad IF you will come on Sat or Sun". Means she's asked about the next class and as I was absent, now you are telling me what was going on at the end of the class.
Another example:
Laura said IF we will be there on Sat.
Laura doesn't know that we will be there on Sat and you are telling me what she said.
0
Thanks, Stephen! That really helped.
0
I didn’t understand that many things but the word “or” is only for the Saturday and Sunday . So for this reason you say or . I’m sorry if I didn’t respond correct but I can’t understand what you mean
0
She asked if they would on Saturday or Sunday. The third possibility (that they will not come at all is not stated butbitnis implied or understood as a possibility.
Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?
Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!
Non perdere l'opportunità di imparare una lingua comodamente da casa tua. Esplora la nostra selezione di insegnanti di lingue esperti e iscriviti subito alla tua prima lezione!
Inizia a imparare oggi
