Grammar: " and why," ?
I'm reading a book and there's this grammar I don't understand:
"This explains why he revised his work so obsessively and why, in spite of his thirty years of writings, we only have slightly more than one thousand of his poems."
This "and why," can be go without the ","? I don't understand why the , is there.
Thank you.Chris, calvin_lau, Peachy, Eliot,. Thank you for answering it helped a lot.
I think I got it now. I need more practice =) Thank you so much.
Cerca tra vari insegnanti di Inglese...
Risposte · 4
2
One reason to use a comma is when you have extra information in the sentence. You use the commas to seperate that information. So your sentence could look like this.
This explains why he revised his work so obsessively and why we only have slightly more than one thousand of his poems."
The extra information is "in spite of his thirty years of writings".
So when it is added into the sentence a comma is put on both sides like your original sentence
"This explains why he revised his work so obsessively and why, in spite of his thirty years of writings, we only have slightly more than one thousand of his poems."
0
They are reported questions so there is no question mark.
The two commas are required to separate the additional phrase "in spite of his 30 years of writing". The sentence can be said without that phrase.
0
Although we know "why" is a question word, it can sit easily in a statement. Both "whys" in the sentence are working this way. Here's how to read it:
"This explains:
1. why he revised his work so obsessively
2. why (in spite of his thirty years of writings) we only have slightly more than one thousand of his poems."
If it were a question, the word order would be different: "...and why, in spite of his thirty years of writings, DO we have ONLY slightly more than one thousand of his poems(?)"
0
I think the sentence between "," is an adverbial phrase. An Adverbial phrase can be put in three position in a sentence, it's front, middle and end. When an adverbial clause is put in the middle, it is rounded by two commas.
Example from my grammar book:
Front: Because of the strike, the teachers have stopped work.
Middle: The teachers, because of the strike, have stopped work.
End: The teachers have stopped work because of the strike.
Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?
Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!
Non perdere l'opportunità di imparare una lingua comodamente da casa tua. Esplora la nostra selezione di insegnanti di lingue esperti e iscriviti subito alla tua prima lezione!
Inizia a imparare oggi
