In the first example, you want the object pronoun "her." You don't want the reflexive pronoun because the coach was rebuking someone else, not "herself." A player misses shots, not the coach. The coach doesn't normally play unless she's a player/coach.
To answer your other question: it would make sense to say that you "blame yourself" for something that goes wrong, but if you "rebuke yourself" it means that you're talking to yourself out loud.
In the second example, you want the reciprocal pronoun "each other." If you use the reflexive pronoun "ourselves", it would either mean that each one would somehow "find" himself independently or that they would have some sort of communal spiritual experience rather than that they would be able to meet each other.