Larry TheLanguageGuy
Репетитор сообщества
"Avoir ou Être" How can I know which one to use when forming the passe composé? Is there a simple rule that will help one to know which of the rwo auxilary verbs (être or avoir) to use before a verb in the compound past tense: J'AI vu mais Je SUIS allé. ???????
29 февр. 2012 г., 20:04
Ответы · 4
1
Hi, I'm not a native speaker, but as far as I know, you would use être with verbs that indicate a change of state or movement. There is an acronym to help you remember them, "DR & MRS VAN DER TRAMP" (devenir, revenir, monter, rester, sortir, venir, aller, naître, descendre, entrer, retourner, tomber, rentrer, arriver, mourir, partir)
29 февраля 2012 г.
1
I think French native speakers will answer this question better than me, but as far as I see, etre is used with exception verbs like entrer, sortir, arriver, partir, aller, venir, descendre, naitre, mourir, monter, tomber, rester, with all their derrivatives (i.e. revenir, devenir), with all reflexive and passive verbs. Avoir fits with everything else.
29 февраля 2012 г.
I remember from my school days (it's 20 years ago so don't quote me) that there are something like 16 verbs which take être. You can surely find a list of them somewhere online.
29 февраля 2012 г.
Все еще не нашли ответы?
Напишите свои вопросы, и пусть вам помогут носители языка!
Larry TheLanguageGuy
Языковые навыки
английский, французский, другой, португальский, испанский, тайский
Изучаемый язык
французский, другой, тайский