寻找适合你的 英语 教师…
Aaron
Help me decide: Russian or Japanese?

I’d like to hear your opinion on my dilemma:

 

I have to work with some Japanese clients at work, who don’t speak any Spanish or English, there is nobody to deal them and given my few Japanese knowledge I have to handle them. And it is a true pleasure, but it is also complicated sometimes, because one single wrong word and they might get seriously offended. Plus the Japanese they use with me is very formal, and it makes it hard to find a translation. I do love Japan, its culture and its language, don’t get me wrong.

 

I have noticed Japanese people are very shy or closed minded or afraid of us, (at least in italki.com) I say this because I write and write to them (and even though they’re learning English or Spanish) and it is hard for me to obtain a serious constant answer to get our learning going…

 

Regarding Russian: I love it, unfortunately I won’t be using it anytime soon (maybe on the world soccer tournament in Russia 2018… though my attendance is not yet confirmed entirely) and the Russians in italki.com are very open, they have sent some invitations to me, I don’t have to be “chasing” them like the Japanese.

 

Last topics to consider:
- Difficulty of both is irrelevant, both use different alphabets than roman, and none of them will be easy, so difficulty has no importance to me.
- I am much better at Japanese than Russian, although I am pretty much a noob in Japanese.
- We do have Russian clients at work, but my Russian workmates can currently cover the demand pretty well.


What would you do?

评论 · 6

2

The way you expressed yourself is clear that you have the desire to learn Japanese, more than Russian. So, go for it! One thing is true, if you want to practice on a regular basis, it'll be difficult. Japaneses are not that introvert whilst with Russians you'd have hundreds of people willing to talk and learn! 

0

Thank you very much guys, next time you visit Monterrey tequila shots are on me. Japanese it is!

 

(PS for KP: I don't think I can handle two new languages at once, the thought of it confuses me already!)

0

Aaron, when I want some beer and icecream, I have both.

PS, as you have no specific goal, and as you arne't obliged to master any of two... you are right. Difficulty is irrelevant.
But why to chose? Why not to learn at any given moment whatever you like at this moment? What if you find a Japanese language partner who is ajust a good company? Or some Russian material you really like? When I registered here I couldnt' even imagine that i'll focus on Arabic:/

"boith use different alphabets"
People can struggle for a long time with an alphabet... but honestly, memorizing all Cyrillic, or Greek or Arabic or... letters is just matter of hours. But Japanese writing is a problem of a different order of complexity)
"none of them will be easy"
tons of Russian idioms coincide with French idioms, most of words and structures map well onto something in English, etc. It is one of the harderst European languages around, but nevertheless... Russian is genticaly realted and culturally connected. I bet, if your goal was just 'reading comprehension', Russian would be a way easier. Japanese might be easier in something as well.

0

Alex, this resoning much remids me of these lines:)

"And as the 34th Rule of Acquisition states: 'Peace is good for business' "
"That's the 35th Rule."
"Oh, you're right. Whats the 34th?"
" 'War is good for business.' It's easy to get them confused."

(from an episode of Star Trek: Deep Space 9)

0

Yeah, I agree with SteveB300.

One thing is to learn a language just for fun and quite another is for some business related issues.And since recently in the USA politics in conjunction with mass media try to escalate confrontation between two countries,you know,nothing is going to be expected 'profitable' in the near future.

So I vote to go for Japanese.

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today