宇翾
“while” my grammar book says to describe something that happened in the past time during another action ,a verb after “while” must be used as continuous tense. for example,the car exploded while I was walking past it. so ,whether it is wrong if I write it as “while I walk past it”?I have seen lots of examples in which verbs after while are used just as simple tense in the past. thank you !
2020年5月14日 05:18
回答 · 2
Hi 宇翾, What you are looking it is something called "interrupted actions" using the past continuous. Interrupted actions: In this case we start with an action that was happening for a long period of time, until it was interrupted by something else. "I was working when the door bell rang". As you can see, the actions were not happening at the same time necessarily or for the same amount of time either. If you said "I was walking past the car when it exploded," that is correct. It just means that the action of walking was interrupted by the car exploded. However, to say "the car exploded while I walked past it" is also grammatically correct. You can use the past simple twice in a sentence when both actions are in the past. The only difference is that it implies that there is less of a connection between the actions. Before, they were connected by one interrupting the other, now it seems more like they just exist together. Overall, you are correct when writing both. If you have nay further questions, feel free to get in touch https://www.italki.com/maddie.
2020年5月14日
As a native speaker, I'd say your version is fine. Maybe some ancient grammar law says it's not but it's usage that counts. Hope that helps and take care as you walk past exploding cars!
2020年5月14日
还未找到你的答案吗?
把你的问题写下来,让母语人士来帮助你!