Why have you left? and Why did you leave?
I know these are the different questions with the different meaning, but I can't understand when and why I should use the first one and when and why I should use the second one. What must happen when I should use the first one? And the second one?
All of us have some thinks, right? Sometimes.
One more example:
If I had a "think A" a year ago, and a month ago, and a week ago etc. In other words whole period of time before now. Then somebody’s telling me "You have a mistake! The "Think A" is incorrect, because ... bla-bla-bla ..., so the "Think B" is correct!" and I believe him. What should I say him after his explanation:
"I thought "Think A" is correct" or
"I’ve thought "Think A" is correct"?
If first one (Past Simple):
I’ve had "Think A" all my life. It’s my life experience. And I haven't specific point of time, so it isn't the Past Simple, right?
If second one (Present Perfect):
I have "Think B" now. I’m thinking "Think B", right? I'm not thinking "Think A" now, so it isn't the Present Perfect, because we use the Present Perfect for an action in the past with a result now, right? If I've cleaned my shoes, so my shoes are clean now.
I hope I haven't done too many mistakes and you'll understand my question.
Ooh, help me please.