寻找适合你的 英语 教师…
Thailand flagBenny
The American /ʊ/ Sound
Hi guys,

I would like to ask if you can tell me which one of the dictionaries below provide the best American /ʊ/ sound as in "book".






Thank you very much in advance.

评论 · 5

5
I'm sure opinions will differ on this, because they're all American pronunciations, but here are my thoughts. I assume you're aiming for the most "standard" pronunciation.

Best: Dictionary.com OR Cambridge. To me, these two sound identical, except that the Cambridge guy says the word faster. This pronunciation sounds the most standard and natural to me.

Good: Merriam-Webster. This one sounds also sounds fine to me, but very slightly different. I think certain US accents are more likely to give you this more emphasized /ʊ/ sound (and the slightly more emphasized /b/ sound). To me this one sounds very slightly less perfectly "standard."

Okay: Macmillan. The guy sounds like he's sort of doing an exaggerated "American accent," almost like an actor or radio show host trying to do a really American American accent. It's a perfectly accurate American accent. Maybe he just seems too excited?

Least-Standard: Oxford American Edition. This girl seems to me to have a bit of a southwestern accent.
2
Thanks @Gray for an excellent analysis.

Thanks @Chris for confirming.

I would like to show you 3 more videos from YouTube. They will start where I want you to listen to. You will only need to listen for 10 seconds max.

Keenyn https://youtu.be/QtYIp5KYk0M?t=20
Rachel https://youtu.be/phlnzlzCPqE?t=56
Victoria https://youtu.be/UStAbfBs4xw?t=80

Do they sound the same as Dictionary.com and Cambridge?

Thank you so much for your help.
2
I agree completely with Gray's evaluation of the best recordings.

Cambridge and dictionary.com are the "most standard" General American pronunciation in my opinion.

Edited: Added some notes about specific pronunciations:

My ranking (slightly different from Gray's ranking):

Cambridge - standard, slightly rounded vowel
dictionary.com - standard, slightly rounded vowel

MacMillan - I hear a slightly raised vowel and a "clipped" fast pronunciation which seems slightly odd.

Oxford - I hear a slightly lowered, unrounded vowel, mid-way between book [bʊk] and buck [bʌk]
M-W - least standard - I hear a lowered, unrounded vowel, very close to buck [bʌk].

Note - I have a Northern California accent from the 1960s which closely matches the General American accent. My accent does not have the California vowel shift which has occurred over last 20 years.
1
@Benny

Yes. The three recordings are the same vowel as in the Cambridge example.
0
@Chris Thank you so much for your expertise.

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today