Cerca tra vari insegnanti di Inglese...
mei
Please explain why the answer is A but not the others?
A. She suggested that he take a break
B. She suggested that he takes a break
C. She suggested he to take a break
D. She suggested he taking a break
2 apr 2025 14:57
Risposte · 4
1
If you want to read more about this structure, it is called the subjunctive. Basically verbs like suggest, recommend, insist, demand, etc. are followed by the verb in the present subjunctive mood. This is identical to the bare infinitive (the infinitive without to). This structure is little used in British English (and, as Dan says, can sound quite pompous). I think it is used more in American English. A British English grammar book will only discuss it briefly in the advanced level book. An American English grammar book might have more detail.
2 aprile 2025
Correct answer: A. She suggested that he take a break.
This is the correct sentence because after verbs like “suggest,” we use the base verb — that means the verb in its simple form, with no “to” and no -s, -ed, or -ing at the end.
For example, the base form of:
takes is take
goes is go
studied is study
eating is eat
So in this sentence, we say:
"She suggested that he take a break." (base verb: take)
This structure is used when we talk about suggestions, wishes, or important actions. It's called the subjunctive, but your main job is just to remember the pattern:
suggest + that + someone + base verb
Why the others are wrong:
B. She suggested that he takes a break
Wrong because “takes” is not the base verb — it has an -s.
C. She suggested he to take a break
Wrong because we don’t use “to” after “suggest someone.”
D. She suggested he taking a break
Wrong because “taking” is the -ing form, not the base verb.
Summary:
A base verb is the verb in its simplest form: no to, no -s, no -ed, no -ing
Use this form after “suggest that”
"She suggested that he take a break."
4 aprile 2025
The academic answer is: only A is correct because after "suggest", we use the base form of the verb (not "takes" or "taking"); and C is wrong because "to" is unnecessary (either remove "to"; or change "he to" into "for him to").
But in reality, a lot of native speakers will say B, especially informally. A is a bit posh - if you speak like this around gangsters of inner-city streets, they will think you're fronting and may pick a fight with you. It's considered the proper way of speaking in a formal tone, but this is a nuance that a lot of less educated native speakers don't know, so I wouldn't recommend worrying about it too much. Most native speakers only know it by 'feeling' it after a lot of experience of hearing this kind of sentence in formal contexts.
2 aprile 2025
Because the verb like suggestions, insist, demand are follow only base verb.
So the suggested is followed by take.
2 aprile 2025
Non hai ancora trovato le tue risposte?
Scrivi le tue domande e lascia che i madrelingua ti aiutino!
mei
Competenze linguistiche
Cinese (mandarino), Inglese, Vietnamita
Lingua di apprendimento
Cinese (mandarino), Inglese
Altri articoli che potrebbero piacerti

Santa, St. Nicholas, or Father Christmas? How Christmas Varies Across English-Speaking Countries
11 consensi · 4 Commenti

Reflecting on Your Progress: Year-End Language Journal Prompts
10 consensi · 3 Commenti

Same Word, Different Meaning: American, British, and South African English
25 consensi · 19 Commenti
Altri articoli
