Hi! Could I tell me which bellow sentence is natural or not? I guess both are almost the same meaning. Which sentence does the native speaker usually use? Is there some different point grammatically?

Takashi

Hi! Could I tell me which bellow sentence is natural or not? I guess both are almost the same meaning. Which sentence does the native speaker usually use? Is there some different point grammatically? Did you have a vacation recently? Have you had a vacation recently? I'm glad if you tell reason also. Thanks in advance.

Jan 4, 2022 11:56 AM

Answers · 5

I think there is a difference between British and American English. As a speaker of British English the second sounds much more natural with the adverb "recently". In British English, "Have you had a vacation recently/yet/this year" all work, whereas "Did you have a vacation" uses the simple past and is better suited to a narrative about the past e.g. "When you were in America, did you have a vacation in summer or in winter?"

January 4, 2022

1st one is more natural

January 4, 2022

Hi, Bhuvan Thank you very much for your quick response. I agree with you what the first sentence is natural. The grammar book 'Grammar in use' I use explained the 2nd is correct. So, I had confused a little. Anyway, I think so the 1st one is more natural than 2nd. Thank you again.

January 4, 2022

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!