zuotengdazuo
Does the sentence make sense? 1. Does "I have eaten roast duck since I lived in China" make sense? 2. If the sentence makes sense, then please check my understanding of the sentence? 1) Assuming I lived in China for 180 days. I may have begun to eat roast duck on day 2. And I have eaten them from then up until now. Day1.....Day2(ate)....Day3.......(ate).................Day180(I left China).......(ate).......Now(still eat) 2)It can also mean "I didn't start to eat roast duck until I left China". In this case, it is identical to "I have eaten roast duck since l left China". Day1.............................(not ate).......................Day180(I left China).......(ate).......Now(still eat) 3. If I force B to respond: "Yes/No. I have eaten roast duck since I lived in China", then how is A supposed to ask the question? Thank you.
Jan 26, 2017 1:21 PM
Answers · 3
To anyone, correct me if i'm wrong but this is what I think is right. 1. Instead of that sentence, it wold be more precise if it were to be a) "I've been eating roast duck ever since I lived in China" or b) "I started eating roast duck ever since I lived/stayed in China." 2. With the sentence I put, the meaning would have been that a) i've been eating roast duck from back when I stayed in China until today. I grew up in China and my actions started from then. b) i've been eating roast duck ever since I started living in China. the action only started from when I was staying in China. 3. i'm not too certain of what you mean by that but I assume that you're asking how A should ask B if B were to answer "yes/no. I've been eating roast duck ever since I lived in China" This is how A should ask : Did you start eating roast duck ever since you came back from China? Again, there are many ways to ask, it depends on the person's point of view in how to question is interpreted and how they wish to answer the question. i'm not that great in explaining but I hope it helped a little ! Please correct me if i'm wrong :) happy learning !
January 26, 2017
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!