Alesia
What does the last sentence mean? "And exactly how was a thinking person supposed to deal with such an absurdly balanced screw-up? Did you laugh? Did you scream? Did you shoot yourself for a yellow dog?" What has it got to do with a yellow dog? Thank you!
Apr 11, 2019 8:05 PM
Answers · 6
2
This an excerpt from the novel Skeleton Crew. Given that Stephen liked to write authors as the protagonist in his books, the narrator (an author) is probably referring to another author's work. A book called Old Yeller. After the dog gets rabies, a boy is forced to shoot him. The boy has a hard time dealing with the dogs death and becomes very despondent. Here, the narrator compares possible reactions to the perceived reversal of fortunes to how the boy in Old Yeller might have reacted. Should the boy have allowed himself to get so depressed about the dog's death that he would be driven to suicide? He's basically saying, hyperbolic reactions to his situation would be unreasonable.
April 12, 2019
1
I think Karl is right. This usage of "for" is a bit unusual, so I thought I'd add a bit more explanation. Here, "for" means that you are regarding one thing (yourself) as being something else (a yellow dog) . The most common place where you'll hear the word "for" used in this way is in the phrase "to take someone for (something)" or "to mistake someone/something for (something/someone else)." For example: "Do you take me for a thief?" ("Do you regard me as a thief?"/"Do you think of me as being a thief?") "What do you take me for?" (meaning: "What kind of person do you think I am?") "I mistook this painting for a photograph." (meaning: "I wrongly thought that the painting was a photograph.") The usage of "for" with the meaning of "regarding something as being something else" used to be more common, and you'll still see it in some other common phrases. To "shoot yourself for a coward" therefore just means "to shoot yourself because you regard yourself as being a coward." I've never personally heard the phrase "yellow dog" used to mean "coward," but the word "yellow" implies cowardice in English, and the word "dog" can mean someone pathetic or worthless, so this interpretation looks right to me.
April 12, 2019
1
A "yellow dog" is a coward. With the sentence "Did you shoot yourself FOR a yellow dog" the meaning is "Did you consider yourself a contemptible coward and shoot yourself because of this?"
April 11, 2019
Could you provide more context?
April 11, 2019
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!