Yuan
Hi, hope a nice day for you. Here is a grammatical question I could have known the answer, as I get confused with the answers of the other sites. Which sentence is correct below? Why? Someone said the sentence 2 was also acceptable in US English. 1. I can play the piano. 2. I can play pianos.
Jan 8, 2025 2:11 PM
Answers · 5
2
Both British and American English typically prefer "play the piano" when referring to the general ability to play the instrument. While the second sentence might technically be accepted in American English in certain contexts (e.g., discussing multiple pianos specifically), it is far less common and sounds unusual in everyday language. Summary Use "I can play the piano" to indicate you can play the instrument in general. Use "I can play pianos" only if you’re emphasizing multiple pianos, which is rare and context-specific.
Jan 8, 2025 2:14 PM
1
Both are correct, but they mean different things: 1. "I can play the piano." This is common. It means you know how to play the instrument in general. 2. "I can play pianos." This is less common. It means you can play more than one piano, like any piano you see. Sentence 1 is more usual in US English.
Jan 9, 2025 12:16 AM
1
1. I can play the piano. * Correct and natural. Use this for general ability. 2. I can play pianos. * Rare. Refers to playing multiple or different types of pianos.
Jan 8, 2025 11:23 PM
1
1. I can play the piano. This is the standard and most commonly used form in both British and American English. It uses the definite article ("the") with a singular noun ("piano") to refer to playing the instrument in general. You’re not talking about a specific piano, but the ability to play that type of instrument. This construction applies to many musical instruments: "I can play the violin." "She can play the guitar." 2. I can play pianos. This sentence is grammatically correct, but it has a different meaning. It suggests that you can play multiple pianos—either simultaneously (which is rare but not impossible) or individually. This phrasing might be used in a more specific context, such as: "I can play pianos, but I prefer organs." "I can play pianos in a showroom to demonstrate their sound." In casual conversation, though, this sentence sounds unusual because people usually talk about their skill with a musical instrument in general terms, not the plural form. Why Sentence 2 May Be Considered Acceptable in U.S. English In informal or less standard usage, Americans sometimes drop "the" when talking about playing musical instruments. For example: "I can play piano." This is fairly common and understood in the U.S., but the plural ("pianos") is rarely used unless you're deliberately emphasizing multiple instruments. Conclusion Sentence 1 is the preferred and widely accepted form. Sentence 2 is grammatically correct but contextually unusual unless you're specifically referring to playing multiple pianos. Let me know if you'd like further clarification! 😊
Jan 8, 2025 10:37 PM
1
‘I play piano.’ is short for ‘I can play the piano.’ (I have the ability) ‘I play the piano’ means either ‘I regularly play (the) piano.’ or ‘I can play the piano.’ I play pianos. (No) I can play pianos (No)
Jan 8, 2025 9:20 PM
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!