Search from various English teachers...
Alex
1. Can I say "I was playing basketball the whole evening. "?
I thought that this tense is about a single moment, for example, "I am playing basketball right now.", "I was playing basketball 5 minutes ago."
But I have just visited a website with explanations and they show that sentence as an example of using of the progressive tense.
I thought that a better option would be "I had been playing basketball the whole evening" because it is about a period and also related to a certain time.
2. Can I say "I had been playing basketball when Mary came."?
I thought that this tense(perfect progressive) is about a period not about one single moment "when Mary came". I thought that exactly here you should say "I was playing basketball when Mary came."
But on the same website they say that not, I have to use "had been playing" instead of "was playing".
Please explain me these 2 situations.
Thank you in advance.
Jul 24, 2021 1:25 PM
Answers · 3
Hello, I’m a native speaker but not a teacher, that’s my disclaimer. :)
The first example “…was playing” can be used in both situations to show both a moment in time as well as through a period of time, but the period of time is known and they are in the past. The thing to remember here is that you’re talking about the past from the PRESENT.
What were you doing when I called?
I was playing basketball.
(The time period is “when I called”)
What were you doing between 5 and 8 pm?
I was playing basketball.
(The time period is 5-8”)
What were you doing all night?
I was playing basketball.
(The time period is “all night”)
Now let’s involve Mary and the “had”
This “had” is used when telling a story about two points that are BOTH in the past.
…had been
…had jumped
…had [any other verb]
In our examples here you’ll be using the word “had” to show that you were doing something in the past when another moment in the past occurred, and you want to make a statement about that second point in the past.
So if Mary called you at 8 pm.
“I HAD been playing basketball, but Mary called.”
Here you are either going to continue talking about Mary or it’s implied that that you’re focusing on that time when Mary called. Either way, you’re in the past at both time points.
Basketball is in the past…Mary’s call is in the past.
You’re emphasizing that second moment in the past about Mary and that the first activity is over.
You could say was “I WAS playing basketball when Mary called,” but in this example you’re not clear that you STOPPED playing when she called. It could be followed with various thoughts:
I was playing basketball when Mary called…
…so I didn’t hear.
…BUT then I stopped.
…so she joined the game.
…and she wanted to play.
“Had” shows you
A) stopped playing
B) are telling a story about what happened when Mary called (in the past), while you were playing basketball (even further in the past).
“Been” makes the activity/verb continuous in the past.
July 24, 2021
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Alex
Language Skills
Chinese (Mandarin), English, Japanese, Russian
Learning Language
Chinese (Mandarin), English, Japanese
Articles You May Also Like

How to Ask for a Raise or Promotion in English
9 likes · 8 Comments

The Key to Learning a Language Faster
30 likes · 8 Comments

Why "General English" is Failing Your Career (An Engineer’s Perspective)
30 likes · 12 Comments
More articles
