It means the person's fate or destiny is now established and cannot be changed.
You could rewrite the sentence as: "...much the same inducements and alarms SEAL THE FATE of any tempted and trembling sinner."
When people say, "The die is cast," they mean that a process has now begun and no one can change the result. They can no longer escape their fate.
The idea behind the saying is that when you roll the dice, as soon as they leave your hand you cannot control the number you will get. Only your luck (or your fate/destiny) will determine the result.