Henry
A dog is a faithful animal = The dog is a faithful dog ? How can I make a sentence that expresses a group of the same thing sharing a common feature? I'm wondering if these three sentences below mean the same totally: (1) A dog is a faithful animal. (2) The dog is a faithful animal. (3) Dogs are faithful animals. Are there any slight differences between the sentences?? Or, (1) A dog has four legs. (2) The dog has four legs. (3) Dogs have four legs. Do those three sentences also have completely the same meaning? I' m curious. Thanks for your help :D
Oct 7, 2011 2:59 AM
Answers · 4
2
Not quite. (1) and (3) are similar in that they are generalised statements. A possible difference between them may depend on their usage. (1) can be used for counting e.g. "A dog has four legs, Two dogs have eight legs, .." (3) can't be used for counting e.g. "Dogs have four legs, Two dogs have more than eight legs, .. (X)" (2) on the other hand, is specific to the 'dog' that the speaker is referring to. In "The dog is a faithful animal", the reader feels that the speaker is referring to a particular dog that is present in the pooled knowledge between the speaker and the reader (one that is established through speaker's speech/text).
October 7, 2011
After the puzzle arose, I consulted a reference book on grammar. It said all the three sentences would be correct. The definite article "the" could be used to refer to a thing in general. Afterwards, I also found this sense in use in the Oxford Advanced Dictionary. In fact, previously, I had the same idea as Maroro's that "the" often indicated the particular thing that both speaker and reader had already known. But I still get information here. I'm grateful for all the replies here.
October 7, 2011
You can use all three. The use of "the" is rare, though.
October 7, 2011
Dogs are faithful animals. Dogs have four legs.
October 7, 2011
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!