Lizzy
I have a query.If and honest man says he's a liar... does that make him an honest man or does that make him a liar? This was brought upon me by my friend, Alejandro, and I've been struck with confusion. Care to clarify? If it does not confuse you itself.
Apr 10, 2012 9:48 PM
Answers · 11
2
Short answer: to hide the truth is a form of lie, and this person is hiding the truth when talking about himself. So he is a liar! /to hide/ implies also: to make it too difficult to discover. There are sentences that have a good syntax and have a meaning only at the surface; so studying the meaning of those sentences is just a waste of time. This is a scientific result that should not be forgotten: the set of logical sentences (that carry a meaning, and have a true/false value) is just a part of the set of syntactical correct sentences. Moreover: there are special sentences that people say and their meaning is not in the words but in the fact that those sentences are said. In this case the true meaning is something like: please pay attention to me, I want to be in the center of the circle. This man would be delighted to know a bunch of people from Italki were studying his words, but that delight shows me more than a moral weakness! Of course this does not confuse me! Please tell us more of this kind of difficult sentences. All in all I will steer away from anybody describing himself in a way that requires such difficult thoughts; his ego seems to me to be hypertrophic, and I would not care a damn about his honesty. Only exception: when all of this is just a joke!
April 11, 2012
2
If a man says he's a liar...does that make him an honest man or does that make him a liar? That depends on what the man wants to achieve. If he is really honest, then there is no need for him to warn people he's a liar. If he wants to get into someone's good books, he may say he's a liar hoping to convince a person that he is really honest.
April 10, 2012
1
nothing is confusing in this its an simple sentance that "does that make him an honest or does that make him a lier" what actually you want to know ?
April 10, 2012
1
I thing everybody who lie is a liar... but,Who haven't lied anytime?. All depend on the the importance of the lie.
April 10, 2012
'If false­hood had, like truth, but one face only, we should be upon better terms with it; for we could then take the contrary of what the liar says for certain truth. But the reverse of truth has a hundred thousand shapes, occupying an undefined territory, without bound or limit.' I read that in 'How to detecte lies' by Paul Ekman.
April 11, 2012
Show more
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!