Carlos Grande
minor or parcial success ? Why the answer is this ? The surgeon told Sam that the operation had been only a minor/partial success. Answer: partial. Thanks a lot in advance!
Jan 7, 2017 10:38 AM
Answers · 5
1
Hi Carlos, In this case we use "partial". The operation only succeeded partially. It was not a complete failure and not a complete success! Hope this helps. :) Pascale
January 7, 2017
1
Carlos, without going too much into detail and the semantics of it, here are the basics. 1) Assume the objective of the operation was to a) extract 5 kidney stone and thus b) reduce the inflammation of the kidneys 2) Assume that you have only managed to c) extract 4 out of 5 stones or d) all 5 but the kidney are still inflated 3) This means that you have achieved PART of your objective a and b. Alternatively, only PART of the operation worked (extracting stones) but the other part (reducing inflammation) did not work 4) I would not say that MINOR is entirely incorrect. But generally, Minor implies "insignificant" and Success implies "great/grand/significant", so in combination they are awkward. Finally, as a doctor, you have to be as precise in communication with patients as possible. Partial success means some things have worked and others have not, so you can have a discussion on that. Minor success is vague and confusing. Peace
January 7, 2017
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!