Search from various English teachers...
bokrrr
"tidak" and "bukan" ?
In indonesian language what is the difference between "tidak" and "bukan" ?
Apr 3, 2013 1:41 AM
Answers · 10
5
both (tidak/bukan) have the same meaning = no/ not.
..but
"tidak" is a negation for statement, disallowance, or refusing.
example:
Statement= Saya tidak suka bunga ini! (I do not like this flower!), Bunga ini tidak harum lagi. (This flower is no longer fragrant.)
Refusing= Saya tidak mau! (I don't want!), Maukah kau menikah denganku? Tidak, saya tidak mau. (Do u want to marry me? No. I do not want.)
Disallowance= Kamu tidak boleh membuka buku saat ujian! (You can not open a book during the exam!)
"bukan" is denial.
example:
Denial= Itu bukan bukuku! (That's not my book!). Kemarin aku melihat seseorang duduk di depan rumahmu, apakah itu kamu?? Bukan! Itu bukan aku. (Yesterday I saw seomeone sitting in front of your house, was that you?? No! That's not me), Ini bukan salahku! (It's not my fault!)
When you deny something, there's always more explanation/ excuse.
using conjunction "tetapi/tapi/melainkan/namun" = BUT.
** Itu bukan bukuku! TAPI, BUKUMU. (that's not my book, but yours.)
** Kemarin aku melihat seseorang duduk di depan rumahmu, apakah itu kamu?? Bukan! Itu bukan aku, TAPI KAKAK PEREMPUANKU. (Yesterday I saw someone sitting in front of your house, was that you?? No! That's not me, but my sister)
Please check out the following link to see more abt the differences between bukan and tidak:
http://bahasakita.com/negation-tidak-bukan-and-belum/
April 3, 2013
Some times "tidak" and "bukan" have same mean. It based on the sentences. And somtimes has different mean.
On this example below, sentence no 1 must use "tidak". But sentence no 2 it can use "bukan".
Apa kamu suka melihat film -> Do you like watching movie?
Saya tidak suka melihat film -> No, i dont like
Apakah kamu seorang guru? -> Are you a teacher?
Bukan, saya bukan seorang guru -> No, i am not
Maybe helpfull. Thank you.
April 3, 2013
"Tidak" means "No" (in verb sentences), and "Bukan" means "Not" (in noun sentences).
December 17, 2013
Actually, 'tidak' and 'bukan' have same mean. But it used in different situation.
June 14, 2013
The main thing: BUKAN negates the noun that comes right after it; TIDAK negates everything else.
"I am not a Russian person." = "Saya bukan orang Rusia."
BECAUSE: the thing being negated is "orang Rusia," and "orang" is a NOUN.
"I do not live in Japan." = "Saya tidak tinggal di Jepang."
BECAUSE: the thing being negated is "tinggal di Jepang," and "tinggal" is NOT A NOUN.
May 21, 2013
Show more
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
bokrrr
Language Skills
Portuguese, Russian
Learning Language
Portuguese, Russian
Articles You May Also Like

How to Ask for a Raise or Promotion in English
9 likes · 8 Comments

The Key to Learning a Language Faster
30 likes · 8 Comments

Why "General English" is Failing Your Career (An Engineer’s Perspective)
30 likes · 12 Comments
More articles
