As stated in the original post above, the app is not designed to make you fluent, something the developers themselves freely admit.
Some of the sentences generated, such as “we are women”, or “our horses don’t drink milk” are strange, but what is being taught here, besides simple vocabulary, is syntax. In real-life situations all learners are required to adapt the language they know to the situation at hand. It should only be a small step then to modify such phrases in order to say, for example, “we are tourists” or “our children don’t drink milk” - or other meaningful variants.
The repetitive nature may sometimes seem tedious but repetition is also a component part of effective language acquisition. The stories, additionally, are spoken by native speakers with authentic voices and phrasing.
The reward messages, though infantile, are similarly formulated to encourage and incentivise – much like the “streak” is designed to persuade the learner to keep coming back, even if it he/she only does 10 minutes each day. Again, repeat learning of small amounts daily has been found to be more effective than, say a few hours each month.
Of course it has its limitations, but do you know of a method that doesn’t – including iTalki?
See my post here:
As a final word, DL, perhaps unique amongst online providers, offers starter courses in many minority languages such as Welsh, Irish, Navajo and Hawaiian. If just 1% of those learners go on to study these at a higher level, then our world will remain a culturally richer place.
Disclaimer: Like David, I have no association with DL