Fixed Punishment or Considering Intentions ?
For a long time, it has been a controversial issue whether there must be fixed punishments for any kind of crimes or the incentives that caused a person to commit a crime should be considered in determining retributions. I will look at both sides of this view and express my own opinion in this essay.
Some people are of the opinion that in modern societies all people are aware of laws and should act according to the regulations. Hence, once one contravenes the rules and makes disturbance for others, should be punished. In this logic, imposing the death penalty on both a murderer who killed a person unintentionally to save his own life and a terrorist who deliberately killed a number of innocent people seems reasonable since they committed the same kind of crime. In other words, when someone kills a person, no matter what the reason was, he should be punished to execute justice in a society. Subsequently, the violence and the rate of crime decline dramatically as felons know there will be severe punishment even for small crimes. Therefore, applying the predetermined law with no exception not only executes justice, but also contributes to safer living conditions for all citizens.
Others, on the other hand, believe that the intentions and motivations that have led a person to engage in an illegal activity should be taken into account before deciding about the retributions. Take, for instance, a woman who stole a loaf of bread from a store to feed her hungry baby and a corrupt government employee who stole millions of dollar to accumulate his wealth. Applying same punishment for these given criminals only because stealing was the crime in both cases, is not justified at all.
To sum up, there are a lot of crimes in which the criminal is not really guilty. Consequently, my opinion is that the punishment for a crime should be made up according to all the factors leading up to an unlawful action rather than classifying fixed punishments for each type of crimes.
Tìm kiếm từ nhiều giáo viên Tiếng Anh...
Bài chữa · 1
1
Fixed Punishment or Considering Intentions ?
For a long time, it has been discussed whether there should be a fixed punishment for a given crime or whether mitigating circumstances should also be considered in the tariff. I look at both sides of this view and express my own opinion in this essay.Some people think that in modern society all people are aware of of the law and should act accordingly. Hence, once one contravenes the rules and disturbs others, one should be punished. By this logic, imposing the death penalty on both the killer who killed unintentionally to save his own life and a terrorist who deliberately killed a number of innocent people seems reasonable since they committed the same kind of crime. In other words, when someone kills a person, for whatever reason, he should be punished to prosecute justice in a society. Subsequently, violence and the crime rate decline dramatically as felons know there will be severe punishment even for infringements. Therefore, applying the predetermined law with no exception not only executes justice, but also contributes to everyone's safety.
Others, on the other hand, believe that the intent and motive that led to crime should also be taken into account before deciding the retribution. Take, for instance, a woman who stole a loaf of bread from a store to feed her hungry baby and a corrupt government employee who stole millions of dollars to add to his his wealth. Applying the same punishment for these given criminals only because stealing was the crime in both cases, is not justified at all.
To sum up, there are a lot of crimes in which the criminal is not really guilty. Consequently, my opinion is that the punishment for a crime should be made up according to all the factors leading up to an unlawful action rather than using fixed punishments for each type of crimes.
very well written!
Bạn muốn tiến bộ xa hơn?
Hãy tham gia cộng đồng học tập này và thử nghiệm những bài tập miễn phí!
Đừng bỏ lỡ cơ hội học ngoại ngữ ngay tại nhà. Hãy xem danh sách các gia sư ngôn ngữ giàu kinh nghiệm của chúng tôi và đăng ký buổi học đầu tiên ngay hôm nay!
Bắt đầu học hôm nay
